Grounds for contesting a will
Testator's lack of capacity
This is the most frequent ground: the testator suffered from dementia or another illness that prevented them from understanding what they were doing. The notary assesses capacity when the will is made, and that assessment carries a very strong presumption. Overturning it requires solid evidence: medical records, neurological reports, dependency assessments and witness statements. Since Law 8/2021, a disability does not prevent a person from making a will if they can form and express their will with appropriate support, as we explain under support measures.
Duress, deceit or fraud
A will made under pressure, threats or deception is void: for example, when a person caring for the testator isolated them from their family and influenced them into naming that person as heir. The evidence is usually indirect.
Formal defects
Each type of will (open notarial, closed, holographic) has its own formalities. A holographic will, written by hand, must be validated before a notary, and its authenticity can be disputed through handwriting evidence.
Failure to appoint an heir
In Mallorca, the appointment of an heir is an essential requirement for a will to be valid, even if the word "heir" is not used, provided the intention is clear (art. 14 of the Compilation). A document that only distributes legacies without appointing an heir is not valid as a will.
Omission and unjust disinheritance
If the will omits a child or disinherits them without cause, this normally only gives the right to claim the forced heirship share, but in some cases it allows the will to be annulled, as we explain under omission and disinheritance.
Common evidence
- The testator's clinical and medical history in the preceding years.
- Statements from the notary and any witnesses.
- Evidence from relatives, carers and healthcare staff.
- Expert medical reports on capacity at the date of the will.
- Handwriting expert evidence for holographic wills.
We help you accept or renounce it in time and without tax surprises.
Time limits
The time limits depend on the ground: the action to annul a will for unintentional omission lapses 4 years after the deceased's death (art. 46 of the Compilation), and actions for nullity based on defects in the will are governed by the general rules. It is advisable to act as soon as possible, before the assets are divided and sold. In addition, since 2025 prior negotiation must be attempted before filing a claim.
Before contesting
Contesting a will is costly and the outcome depends on the evidence. Before starting, we analyse the documents, assess the prospects and explore the possibility of an agreement on the division of the estate, which is often the best way out for everyone.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I contest my father's will if he had Alzheimer's?
Yes, if it can be proved that, at the time he made the will, he could not form or express his wishes. The medical evidence from that date is decisive.
How long do I have to contest a will?
It depends on the ground. In Mallorca, annulment for unintentional omission lapses 4 years after the death. Other actions have their own time limits.
Is a handwritten will valid?
Yes, if it meets the requirements for a holographic will and is validated before a notary. Its authenticity can be disputed with handwriting expert evidence.
Can the notary be wrong about capacity?
The notary's assessment carries a very strong presumption, but it can be overturned with clear evidence that the testator lacked capacity at that time.
What happens if the will is annulled?
The previous valid will applies, if there is one, or else the rules of intestate succession.