What the lex artis is
Medicine is an obligation of means, not of results: the doctor does not guarantee a cure, but must use all the means that medical science requires. The lex artis is the standard for judging whether they acted correctly, taking into account the speciality, the complexity of the case, the patient's condition and the resources available. In elective or voluntary medicine, such as cosmetic surgery, the standard regarding results and information is higher.
Typical cases
- Errors or delays in diagnosis, especially in emergency departments and in cancer cases.
- Surgical errors and poorly treated complications.
- Hospital-acquired infections.
- Injuries to the baby or the mother during childbirth.
- Medication errors.
- Lack of informed consent or incomplete information about risks.
We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.
Public or private healthcare
| Public healthcare | Private healthcare | |
|---|---|---|
| Who the claim is against | The Balearic Islands public health service, for financial liability | The doctor, the clinic and their insurers |
| Time limit | One year from recovery or from when the extent of the after-effects is determined | Five years (contractual) or one year from when the damage became known (non-contractual) |
| Route | Administrative claim followed by an appeal to the administrative courts | Prior negotiation and a civil lawsuit |
In public healthcare we can also bring a direct claim against the health service's insurer. We coordinate the administrative route with our administrative law department.
The evidence: medical records and expert report
- Complete medical records: patients are entitled to obtain a copy. They are the basis of any claim.
- Medical expert report by an independent specialist, analysing whether the lex artis was respected and quantifying the after-effects.
- Assessment of the damage: the courts usually use the road traffic accident scale as a guide, as we explain in road traffic accidents.
If, according to the expert, the case is not viable, we will tell you before starting any proceedings.
We value your compensation before you accept any offer.
Criminal proceedings?
Only in cases of serious or less serious negligence resulting in injury or death is the criminal route appropriate, which we explain in injuries caused by negligence. In most cases the civil or administrative route is more effective for obtaining compensation.
How we work
We study your case, request the medical records, find the right expert and give you a realistic assessment before claiming. If you were treated in Mallorca while on holiday or now live abroad, we can handle the claim remotely and in English. More information in claims.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to claim for medical negligence?
In public healthcare, one year from recovery or from the stabilisation of the after-effects. In private healthcare, five years if there is a contract and one year otherwise.
What is the lex artis?
The body of knowledge and practices that a diligent professional in that speciality must apply. If they are not applied, there is negligence.
Do I need a medical expert?
Yes. The independent expert report is the main evidence of the negligence and of the after-effects.
Can I claim if I signed the informed consent form?
Yes, if there was malpractice. Signing the consent form does not cover medical errors, only the risks you were told about.
How much compensation could I receive?
It depends on the after-effects, the days of recovery and the financial losses. The courts usually take the traffic accident scale as a guide.