First of all: your obligations as the insured
Many refusals by insurers are based on a failure by the insured. It is worth complying carefully with these duties:
- Report the loss within seven days of becoming aware of it, unless the policy allows longer. If you are late, the insurer may claim the damage caused by the delay, but it is not released if it learnt of the loss by other means (art. 16 LCS).
- Provide information on the circumstances of the loss. The right to the indemnity is only lost for breach of this duty in the case of wilful misconduct or gross negligence (art. 16 LCS).
- Mitigate the consequences with the means available to you; reasonable salvage costs are borne by the insurer (art. 17 LCS).
- Send a list of damage under property insurance, in writing and within five days of notifying the loss (art. 38 LCS).
Common grounds for refusing claims in Mallorca and how to rebut them
| Ground given | What the law says |
|---|---|
| "The risk is not covered" or "policy exclusion" | Clauses limiting the insured's rights must be highlighted and specifically accepted in writing; otherwise they may not be enforceable (art. 3 LCS). |
| "You did not declare the risk correctly when taking out the policy" | You only have to declare what the questionnaire asks; without wilful misconduct or gross negligence, the payment is reduced proportionally, not lost (art. 10 LCS). |
| "You reported the loss late" | Delay does not extinguish the right to the indemnity; at most it allows the insurer to claim the damage caused by the late notice (art. 16 LCS). |
| "The damage is due to wear and tear or poor maintenance" | This is a technical issue to be countered with your own expert report. |
General terms and conditions may never be detrimental to the insured (art. 3 LCS). If a clause empties the cover of content, it may also be unfair, as we explain in our guide on unfair terms.
We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.
When the insurer pays too little: the appraisal procedure
Under property insurance, if the insured and the insurer do not agree on the amount within the period in article 18, the law provides for an appraisal procedure (art. 38 LCS):
- Each party appoints an appraiser. If one fails to do so within eight days of being asked by the other, it is bound by the other party's appraiser's report.
- If the appraisers agree, they sign a joint record stating the causes of the loss, the valuation of the damage and the proposed indemnity.
- If not, a third appraiser is appointed by mutual agreement or, failing that, through voluntary jurisdiction proceedings or before a notary.
- The report is binding unless challenged in court: the insurer has thirty days and the insured one hundred and eighty from notification.
If the report is not challenged, the insurer must pay within five days. And if you have to claim it in court because of the insurer's delay, the indemnity is increased by article 20 interest and the costs of the proceedings (art. 38 LCS).
Default interest under article 20
This is the main incentive for insurers to pay on time. Interest accrues from the date of the loss, is imposed by the court of its own motion and consists of the statutory interest rate increased by 50%, with a minimum of 20% a year from two years after the loss (art. 20 LCS). It is excluded only if the failure to pay is due to a justified cause or one not attributable to the insurer.
Out-of-court complaints against the insurer
- Written claim to the insurer, with the expert report, photographs, invoices and the relevant articles of law.
- The insurer's customer service department or customer ombudsman, which must reply within the period set by the rules on customer service.
- The supervisor's complaints service (the Directorate-General for Insurance and Pension Funds, or whichever body has that function), which you can approach after complaining to the insurer.
Since Organic Act 1/2025, before filing a civil claim you must generally use an appropriate dispute resolution method, and direct negotiation between the parties or their lawyers satisfies this requirement (art. 5). A well-reasoned complaint with a specific proposal fulfils that function and also interrupts the limitation period (art. 7).
Suing the insurer in the courts of Palma, Inca or Manacor
If the insurer does not change its position, the route is a civil claim. The court of the insured's domicile has jurisdiction, and any agreement to the contrary is void (art. 24 LCS): if you live in Mallorca, your case will be heard by the Court of First Instance (Tribunal de Instancia) of Palma, Inca or Manacor, depending on your judicial district. Bear the deadline in mind: two years for property insurance and five for personal insurance (art. 23 LCS).
If the person who suffered the damage is a third party, for example the downstairs neighbour affected by your water leak or the victim of a road traffic accident, they can claim directly against the liability insurer through the direct action (art. 76 LCS). In water damage to buildings, the owners' association insurance is also often involved.
At Castell Abogados we review your policy, coordinate the appraisal and negotiate or litigate against the insurer, in Spanish, English or German, as part of our claims service.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
How long does the insurer have to pay me?
It must pay once investigations and appraisals are complete and, in any event, pay the minimum amount within forty days of the claim notification. If it does not pay within three months of the loss, it is in default (arts. 18 and 20 LCS).
What interest must the insurer pay if it is late?
The statutory interest rate increased by 50% from the date of the loss and, after two years, no less than 20% a year (art. 20 LCS).
Can I appoint my own appraiser?
Yes. Under property insurance, if there is no agreement on the amount, each party appoints an appraiser and, if they disagree, a third is appointed (art. 38 LCS).
How long do I have to sue my insurer?
Two years for property insurance and five for personal insurance (art. 23 LCS). It is best not to leave it to the last minute.
Where must I sue if the insurer is based in Madrid?
In the court of your domicile as the insured. Any clause stating otherwise is void (art. 24 LCS).