The complex financial products most often claimed
- Preference shares (participaciones preferentes): perpetual instruments with no repayment date, whose returns depended on the bank's profits and which could suffer losses.
- Subordinated debt: loans to the bank which, in insolvency, are paid after ordinary creditors.
- Swaps or interest rate swaps: hedging contracts, often sold alongside a mortgage or business loan, which could generate large negative settlements and a high cancellation cost.
- Structured bonds and products with derivatives: their return depends on the performance of shares or indices and they can involve the loss of part of the capital.
Act 6/2023 treats as non-complex, for example, listed shares or units in certain harmonised funds, and expressly excludes instruments that embed derivatives or a structure that makes it difficult to understand the risks (art. 208). The products above generally fall into the complex category.
What obligations the bank had when selling the product
Since the European MiFID rules were transposed at the end of 2007, and today under Act 6/2023, a firm providing investment services must act honestly, fairly and professionally in the best interests of the customer (art. 197). In particular:
- Information that is fair, clear and not misleading, including advertising (art. 200).
- Suitability assessment when giving advice or managing portfolios: the firm must know the customer's knowledge, experience, financial situation, ability to bear losses and objectives (art. 204).
- Appropriateness assessment for other services: the firm must assess whether the customer understands the product and warn them if it is not appropriate; for complex products, the contract must include a handwritten statement by the customer acknowledging that warning (art. 205).
Signing a standard form is not in itself enough to prove that the customer understood the risk. The courts look at the customer's real profile, the information received before contracting and the way the product was offered.
We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.
Routes to a claim: nullity for mistake or damages
| Route | What you obtain | Time limit |
|---|---|---|
| Nullity for mistake vitiating consent (arts. 1265, 1266 and 1300 Civil Code) | Return of the capital invested with interest, less the returns received (art. 1303 Civil Code) | Four-year expiry period (art. 1301 Civil Code) |
| Damages for breach of the duty to inform (art. 1101 Civil Code) | Compensation for the loss suffered, usually the net loss | Five-year limitation period (art. 1964.2 Civil Code) |
For mistake, the Civil Code starts the period on the "consummation" of the contract. For long-term complex products, the case law of the Spanish Supreme Court does not place it on the date of signing but at the moment the customer could have become aware of the mistake, for example when returns stopped being paid or the issuing bank was taken over by the authorities. Calculating this period correctly is the first thing we check.
How to claim for preference shares or swaps from Mallorca
- Collect the documents: purchase order or contract, appropriateness or suitability test, brochures, statements and swap settlements.
- Complain in writing to the bank's customer service department, which must resolve within one month.
- CNMV complaints service (the Spanish securities regulator) if the answer is unsatisfactory or does not arrive; its report is not binding, but can be useful as evidence.
- Appropriate dispute resolution method required by Organic Act 1/2025 before a civil claim, which can be met by a documented negotiation.
- Court claim before the competent Court of First Instance; in Mallorca, Palma, Inca or Manacor depending on the judicial district.
Claims about bank fees follow a similar preliminary route through the bank and the supervisor.
Swaps in businesses and heirs of savers in the Balearic Islands
Many swaps were taken out by tourism businesses, shops and developers in the Balearic Islands when refinancing loans. Being a business does not prevent a claim, but the customer's financial experience and whether it was classified as a retail or professional client are examined more closely. In consumer loans, the swap may coexist with other reviewable clauses, as explained in unfair terms.
Actions for nullity and damages pass to the heirs. If your father or mother invested in preference shares, the heirs can claim after accepting the inheritance, provided they are within the time limit. We work in English, German, Spanish and Mallorquin.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can preference shares still be claimed?
It depends on when you could have become aware of the mistake and whether there has already been an exchange, sale or settlement with the bank. The nullity period is four years and the damages period five, with a starting point that must be examined in each case.
What is a swap and why are claims brought?
It is an interest rate swap sold as insurance against rising rates. When rates fell, it generated payments to the bank and a high cancellation cost that many customers were unaware of.
Does having signed the appropriateness test prevent me from claiming?
No. The test is an obligation of the bank, and the courts assess whether the information was real and understandable and whether the product matched your profile.
Can a Mallorca business claim over a swap?
Yes, although its financial experience and whether it was treated as a retail or professional client are taken into account.
Do I have to go to the CNMV before going to court?
It is not compulsory, but you must first complain to the bank and meet the requirement to attempt an appropriate dispute resolution method before suing.