The key difference: who is liable for the debts
The sole trader: unlimited liability
The individual entrepreneur and the business are one and the same person. That is why they are liable for debts to suppliers, banks, the tax authorities or employees with all their assets: accounts, home, vehicles and future income (art. 1911 of the Civil Code).
Law 14/2013 on support for entrepreneurs allows you to register as a Limited Liability Entrepreneur (Emprendedor de Responsabilidad Limitada) and exclude from business debts your main home if its value does not exceed 300,000 euros, as well as certain items of equipment, provided this is recorded at the Commercial Registry (art. 8). It does not protect anyone who has acted fraudulently or with gross negligence as established by a final judgment or in culpable insolvency proceedings, and it leaves the rest of your assets exposed.
In Mallorca, the default matrimonial property regime is separation of property (art. 3 of the Compilation of Civil Law of the Balearic Islands). Each spouse has their own assets, which in principle shields the other spouse's property from the business debts, unless they have signed or guaranteed transactions.
The limited company: liability limited to the capital
A limited company has its own legal personality from its registration at the Commercial Registry (art. 33 of the Capital Companies Act). The shareholders contribute capital and are not personally liable for the company's debts (art. 1.2): if the business fails, in principle they lose what they put in, not their house.
This protection has limits worth knowing:
- Personal guarantees: banks and many landlords of business premises require the shareholders to give personal guarantees. For that particular debt, the limitation disappears.
- Acts before registration: those who signed contracts on behalf of the company before it was registered are jointly and severally liable for them, with some exceptions (art. 36).
- Single-member company: single-member status must be registered; if six months pass without doing so, the sole shareholder is personally and fully liable for the debts of that period (art. 14).
- Directors' liability: whoever manages the company may be personally liable if they breach their duties, for example by failing to promote a winding-up when there are serious losses. We explain this in our guide on directors' liability.
Capital, incorporation and management of an SL in Mallorca
| Aspect | Sole trader | Limited company |
|---|---|---|
| Liability | Unlimited, with all assets | Shareholders are not liable for company debts |
| Minimum capital | None | 1 euro, with special rules below 3,000 euros |
| Starting up | Tax and Social Security registration | Public deed and registration at the Commercial Registry |
| Accounting | Books according to the tax regime | Annual accounts prepared within three months and filed |
| Admitting partners | Not possible as such | Through company shares |
| Closing down | Deregistration | Formal dissolution, liquidation and removal from the register |
On minimum capital, article 4.1 of the Capital Companies Act allows a company to be formed with one euro, but until it reaches 3,000 euros it must allocate at least 20% of profits to the legal reserve until that figure is reached, and if on a winding-up the assets are insufficient to pay the debts, the shareholders are jointly and severally liable for the difference between 3,000 euros and the subscribed capital.
Management can be organised with a sole director, several directors acting jointly or severally, or a board (art. 210). The annual accounts must be prepared within a maximum of three months from the financial year end (art. 253) and filed with the Commercial Registry within one month of their approval (art. 279).
We advise you before the dispute grows.
Social Security and tax for sole traders and companies
Setting up a company does not automatically take you out of the self-employed scheme: anyone who performs management functions as a director, or provides services to the company on a regular, personal and direct basis, and has effective control of it, is included in the special scheme for self-employed workers (art. 305.2.b of the General Social Security Act). Effective control is deemed to exist, in any event, where their shares represent at least half of the capital.
For tax purposes, a sole trader pays income tax (IRPF) on their profits and a company pays corporation tax. Which is more advantageous depends on the level of profit, how much is drawn from the business and each personal situation, and should be calculated by a tax adviser with your actual figures. Be wary of general rules of thumb circulating without up-to-date figures.
When should you be a sole trader or set up a company in Mallorca?
Being a sole trader is often enough when
- The activity carries little financial risk and hardly generates debts to third parties (for example, professional services without employees).
- You are testing a business idea and want to start with the minimum administrative burden.
- There are no partners and none are expected.
A company is usually advisable when
- The activity involves significant risks: hiring staff, building works, leasing premises, investment with financing.
- There are several partners and it is advisable to regulate their contributions, decision-making and how each can leave.
- You want to separate family assets clearly from the business, for example when you own property on the island.
- You intend to sell the business or bring in investors in the future.
If you choose a company, we can assist with its incorporation, the shareholders' agreement and day-to-day commercial contracts. More information in our commercial law practice. And if, as a sole trader, you already have debts you cannot pay, the Second Chance Law may be the way out.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Am I liable with my home if I am a sole trader?
In principle, yes: a sole trader is liable with all their assets. The Limited Liability Entrepreneur status allows you to protect your main home worth up to 300,000 euros if it is recorded at the Commercial Registry and the requirements are met.
What is the minimum capital for a limited company?
One euro. But until the capital reaches 3,000 euros, a legal reserve must be built up from part of the profits and the shareholders are liable for the difference up to that amount if the company is wound up without sufficient assets.
If I set up a company, do I stop being self-employed?
Not necessarily. If you are a director or work for the company and have effective control of it, you will remain in the self-employed scheme.
Can I switch from sole trader to company later?
Yes. It is common to start as a sole trader and set up a company when the business grows, transferring the assets or activity to it. It should be planned with legal and tax advice.
Does a limited company protect me from everything?
No. Personal guarantees, acts before registration and breach of your duties as a director can make you liable with your own assets.