Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Claims guide

Dental negligence in Mallorca: how to claim against a dentist or dental clinic

A badly placed implant, a nerve injured during an extraction, orthodontic treatment that worsens the bite, or treatment paid for in advance that the clinic never finishes. Dental negligence is common and, since most dentistry is provided in private clinics, claims are almost always brought through the civil courts. We explain what counts as negligence, what time limits apply and how to prepare your claim.

What counts as dental negligence?

As in the rest of medicine, a dentist does not guarantee a perfect result, but must use the means and technique their speciality requires: this is the lex artis. Article 1104 of the Civil Code defines fault as the failure to exercise the diligence required by the nature of the obligation, according to the circumstances of the persons, time and place. In cosmetic treatments, such as veneers or whitening, the standards for information and results are usually higher.

Common cases we see in Mallorca:

  • Implants that are badly positioned, fail or invade the maxillary sinus.
  • Injury to the inferior alveolar or lingual nerve after an extraction or implant, with loss of sensation.
  • Extraction of the wrong tooth or of healthy teeth.
  • Orthodontic treatment causing root resorption or bite problems.
  • Infections that are not diagnosed or are poorly treated.
  • Defective prostheses and paid treatment left unfinished because the clinic closed.

Liability of the dental clinic and the dentist

There is normally a contract with the clinic, and negligent performance gives rise to a duty to compensate (art. 1101 Civil Code). In addition, the patient is a consumer and healthcare services are subject to the special liability regime in Article 148 of the consolidated General Act for the Protection of Consumers and Users. You can claim against the clinic, the practitioner and their liability insurers.

RouteWhenTime limit
Contractual (arts. 1101 and 1104 Civil Code)Against the clinic or dentist with whom you contracted the treatmentFive years (art. 1964.2 Civil Code)
Non-contractual (art. 1902 Civil Code)Against whoever caused the damage without a direct contractual relationshipOne year from when you learned of the damage (art. 1968.2 Civil Code)
CriminalOnly in cases of gross or less serious negligence with significant injuryThe limitation periods for the offence

An out-of-court claim interrupts the limitation period (art. 1973 Civil Code), so it is advisable to send one by a verifiable means as soon as possible. The criminal route is only appropriate in the most serious cases; we explain it in negligent injury.

Do you think you have been overcharged?

We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.

Act 41/2002 on patient autonomy requires free and voluntary consent after receiving information about the purpose, nature, risks and consequences of the procedure (arts. 4 and 8). It must be in writing for surgery and for invasive diagnostic and therapeutic procedures (art. 8.2), which includes implant surgery and surgical extractions. Before you sign, the practitioner must explain the certain consequences, the typical risks, the risks specific to you and the contraindications (art. 10.1).

If a risk you were not told about materialises, there may be liability even if the technique was correct. We cover this in lack of informed consent.

How to prepare a dental negligence claim in Mallorca

  1. Ask for your clinical records, including X-rays, CT scans, quotes and signed consent forms. You have the right to access them and obtain a copy (art. 18 of Act 41/2002), and the clinic must keep them for at least five years from discharge for each episode of care (art. 17.1).
  2. Document your current condition with photographs and a report from another dentist before the damage is repaired, so the evidence is not lost.
  3. Commission an independent dental expert report assessing whether there was malpractice and quantifying the damage: the cost of redoing the treatment, pain, days of recovery and after-effects such as loss of sensation. To value the injuries it is common to use the traffic injury scale as a guide.
  4. Claim in writing against the clinic and its insurer. Before suing in the civil courts you must try an appropriate dispute resolution method (art. 5 of Organic Act 1/2025), and serious negotiation with the insurer resolves many cases.

Financed dental treatment and clinics that close in the Balearic Islands

Many treatments are paid for with a loan offered by the clinic itself. If that credit serves exclusively to finance the treatment and both contracts form a commercial unit, it is a linked credit agreement (art. 29.1 of Act 16/2011 on consumer credit agreements). If the treatment is not provided, in whole or in part, or does not match what was agreed, and you have claimed against the clinic without obtaining satisfaction, you can exercise the same rights against the lender (art. 29.3). Also check the loan terms in case they contain unfair terms.

If the damage occurred in a public health centre in the Balearic Islands, the claim is for state liability, with a one-year time limit from recovery or from the determination of after-effects, as we explain in medical negligence. For other consumer disputes, see our page on claims.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to claim for dental negligence in Mallorca?

If you contracted the treatment with the clinic, five years (art. 1964.2 Civil Code). If there is no contract, one year from when you learned of the damage. A written claim interrupts the period.

Do I need an expert?

Yes. An independent dentist's report is the main evidence of malpractice and of the damage, and it helps when negotiating with the insurer.

Can the clinic refuse to give me my dental records?

No. You have the right to access them and obtain a copy, including X-rays, subject only to the reservations in art. 18 of Act 41/2002.

What if the clinic closed and I am still paying the loan?

If the credit was linked to the treatment and you claimed unsuccessfully against the clinic, you can raise against the lender the same rights you had against the clinic.

Can I claim even though I signed the consent form?

Yes, if there was malpractice. Consent covers the risks you were told about, not technical errors.

You may also be interested in