Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Claims guide

Lack of informed consent in Mallorca: patients' rights and claiming compensation

Before an operation, an invasive test or a risky treatment, patients have the right to know what is going to be done, why, and what could go wrong, and to decide freely. If you are not informed and a risk nobody explained materialises, you can claim even if the procedure was technically correct. We explain what Act 41/2002 on patient autonomy requires and how to claim in Mallorca.

Act 41/2002 starts from a principle: every healthcare intervention generally requires the patient's prior consent, which must be obtained after adequate information (art. 2.2). The patient may choose between the available clinical options and refuse treatment, except in cases provided for by law (art. 2.3 and 2.4).

Article 8.2 states that consent is generally verbal, but must be given in writing in the following cases:

  • Surgical operations.
  • Invasive diagnostic and therapeutic procedures, such as endoscopies, catheterisations or biopsies.
  • In general, procedures involving risks or drawbacks with significant and foreseeable adverse effects on the patient's health.

Written consent is required for each of those interventions and must contain sufficient information about the procedure and its risks (art. 8.3). The patient may freely withdraw it in writing at any time (art. 8.5).

What information you must be given before signing

Article 10.1 lists the basic information the practitioner must provide before obtaining written consent:

Mandatory informationExample
Relevant consequences that the procedure will certainly causeA scar, loss of an organ or a period of immobilisation
Risks linked to the patient's personal or professional circumstancesHigher risk due to diabetes, smoking or the patient's occupation
Probable risks under normal conditions or directly related to the type of procedureInfection, bleeding or nerve damage typical of that surgery
ContraindicationsIncompatibility with a medicine or a pre-existing condition

The information must be truthful, understandable and adapted to the patient's needs (art. 4.2). The more uncertain the outcome of a procedure, the more necessary written consent becomes (art. 10.2). A generic form, signed in a hurry without explaining the specific risks of your case, may not comply with the law. For foreign patients in Mallorca, understanding the language is also a factor to be assessed.

Do you think you have been overcharged?

We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.

Doctors may act without consent in only two cases: where there is a risk to public health for health reasons established by law, and where there is an immediate serious risk to the patient's physical or mental integrity and it is not possible to obtain their authorisation, consulting their relatives where circumstances allow (art. 9.2).

If the patient is unable to decide, consent is given by representation (art. 9.3): by their legal representative or by people linked to them by family or de facto ties. For minors who cannot understand the scope of the procedure, their legal representative decides after hearing their views. From the age of 16, or if the minor is emancipated, consent by representation is not possible, except for procedures posing a serious risk to their life or health (art. 9.4). If the patient has a disability, they must be offered the support they need to consent for themselves (art. 9.7), in line with support measures for people with disabilities.

Yes. Lack of information is a separate breach of the lex artis: Article 2.6 requires every professional not only to perform their technique correctly but also to comply with their duties of information and documentation. Claims are mainly brought where:

  1. A risk you were not told about materialises, even if the procedure was technically correct. The recoverable harm depends on whether, properly informed, the patient could have refused the procedure or chosen an alternative.
  2. There was no written consent when it was mandatory, or the document was generic and did not cover the risks of your case.
  3. A different or more extensive procedure was performed than the one consented to.

As consent must be recorded in the clinical records for hospital admissions (art. 15.2), the first step is to request a copy (art. 18). In practice, it is the healthcare provider that can be required to prove it gave adequate information, and simply signing a form is not always enough.

How to claim in public and private healthcare in the Balearic Islands

In public healthcare in the Balearic Islands, the claim is for state liability within one year from recovery or the determination of after-effects (art. 67.1 of Act 39/2015), handled with our administrative law team. In private healthcare, a contractual claim is time-barred after five years (art. 1964.2 of the Civil Code) and a non-contractual one after one year (art. 1968.2), and before suing in the Courts of First Instance (Tribunales de Instancia) of Palma, Inca or Manacor you must try an appropriate dispute resolution method (art. 5 of Organic Act 1/2025).

Lack of information often goes hand in hand with other failings, such as a misdiagnosis or dental negligence with an implant. We analyse the signed document, the clinical records and, with an expert, whether the risk was typical and should have been explained. More information in medical negligence and on our claims page.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always have to be given a written consent form?

No. Consent is generally verbal, but it must be written for surgery, invasive procedures and interventions with significant risks of adverse effects (art. 8.2 of Act 41/2002).

Can I claim if the operation went well technically but I suffered a risk nobody explained?

Yes. Failing to inform you of a risk that materialises can give rise to liability even if the technique was correct.

Can I withdraw my consent after signing?

Yes. The patient may freely withdraw it in writing at any time (art. 8.5).

Who signs the consent if the patient cannot decide?

Their legal representative or people linked to them by family or de facto ties. Those aged 16 and over decide for themselves, except where there is a serious risk to their life or health.

What is the time limit to claim against a public hospital in Mallorca?

One year from recovery or from the determination of the extent of the after-effects (art. 67.1 of Act 39/2015).

You may also be interested in