Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Offences against public order

Disobedience and resistance to authority in Spain

Seriously refusing to comply with an officer's order or resisting arrest without actually attacking anyone can be the offence of disobedience or resistance. If the disobedience is minor, it is normally only an administrative infringement. We explain where the line lies.

What article 556 punishes

The offence of disobedience and resistance punishes anyone who, without going as far as committing assault on authority (atentado), seriously resists or disobeys the authority or its officers while they are performing their duties, or duly identified private security staff who cooperate under the command of the security forces.

Serious disobedience

It requires an express, clear and lawful order, addressed personally to the accused, which they know about and openly refuse to obey. Examples are repeatedly refusing to identify yourself or to leave a cordoned-off area after several requests, or failing to comply with an express court order.

Resistance

This is passive or low-intensity physical opposition, without attack: struggling to avoid being handcuffed, throwing yourself to the ground or holding on to something to prevent being taken away. If the resistance is serious, with violence or serious intimidation, it is atentado.

Penalties

CasePenalty
Serious resistance or disobedience (art. 556.1)Imprisonment of 3 months to 1 year or a fine of 6 to 18 months
Lack of respect to the authority in the exercise of its duties (art. 556.2)Fine of 1 to 3 months
Minor disobedience or resistance to officersSerious administrative infringement under Organic Law 4/2015
Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

Disobedience to court decisions

Clearly and repeatedly failing to comply with an express court order can also be disobedience. When what is breached is a penalty or interim measure already imposed, such as a restraining order or a driving ban, the applicable offence is breach of sentence (quebrantamiento de condena).

How it is defended

  • The order: whether it was clear and lawful and was communicated personally to the accused.
  • The seriousness: many acts charged as offences are minor disobedience that deserves only an administrative penalty.
  • The lawfulness of the police action: there is no offence if the order was not lawful.
  • The evidence: recordings, witnesses and the consistency of the police report.

These events usually occur during an arrest and are often tried as a fast-track trial. A foreign national who does not understand the officers' instructions is entitled to an interpreter, and a language barrier can be relevant when assessing whether the order was understood.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Is it an offence to refuse to identify yourself to the police?

It is normally an administrative infringement. It can only be an offence if the refusal is serious, repeated and defiant after clear requests and warnings.

What is the difference between resistance and atentado?

Resistance is passive or low-intensity opposition. Atentado requires an attack, charging at the officer or serious resistance with violence or serious intimidation, and carries much higher penalties.

Is insulting a police officer an offence?

Showing a lack of respect to the authority in the exercise of its duties is a minor offence punished with a fine of 1 to 3 months. Towards officers, it is normally an administrative infringement.

Can I disobey a security guard?

If the guard is identified and acting in cooperation with and under the command of the police, serious disobedience can be an offence.

What is the penalty for serious disobedience?

Imprisonment of 3 months to 1 year or a fine of 6 to 18 months.

You may also be interested in