The admissibility requirement
Organic Law 1/2025 on measures to improve the efficiency of the Public Justice Service requires, in ordinary declaratory proceedings and in the special proceedings of the Civil Procedure Act, that an appropriate means of dispute resolution has been attempted beforehand. It affects, among others:
- Contested divorces and variations of orders.
- Claims for money and damages, such as those handled by our claims department.
- Disputes over inheritances, co-ownership, leases and contracts.
For the requirement to be met, the subject matter of the negotiation must be the same as that of the later litigation.
Valid means
- Mediation: a neutral mediator helps the parties reach their own agreement.
- Conciliation before a notary, a land registrar, a court clerk or another conciliator.
- Neutral opinion of an independent expert.
- Confidential binding offer, which requires a lawyer's assistance.
- Direct negotiation between the parties, or between their lawyers following their instructions and with their consent, or a collaborative law process.
We explain your options and how to protect your children before you take any step.
Exceptions
Prior negotiation is not required in, among other cases, the protection of fundamental rights, measures under article 158 of the Civil Code to protect minors, support measures for people with disabilities, parentage, summary recovery of possession, bill of exchange proceedings, enforcement, pre-action interim measures and most non-contentious (voluntary jurisdiction) proceedings.
Mediation in family disputes
In family matters, mediation has particular advantages:
- Decisions about the children are taken by their parents, not by a third party.
- It reduces the emotional and financial cost compared with a contested divorce.
- Agreements reached are usually better complied with.
- It is confidential: what is said in mediation cannot later be used at trial.
The agreement reached is set out in a settlement agreement, which is approved by the court or before a notary.
The lawyer's role
Although mediation does not require a lawyer, it is advisable to have one to advise you before and during the process, review the agreement and, if there is no agreement, properly prove that the requirement was met so that you can file a claim. In many cases negotiation between lawyers is the most effective way of meeting it.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Is it mandatory to go to mediation before a contested divorce?
Not necessarily mediation, but you must use some appropriate means of dispute resolution, which can be negotiation between lawyers.
What happens if the other party does not want to negotiate?
If it has been attempted in good faith and the other party does not respond or rejects an agreement, the requirement is considered met and the claim can be filed.
Can what I say in mediation be used at trial?
No. Mediation is confidential.
Which matters do not require prior negotiation?
Among others, parentage, support measures for people with disabilities, urgent child protection measures, enforcement and interim measures.
Does it apply to dismissals?
No. Employment matters are excluded; for dismissals, the employment courts' own prior conciliation procedure still applies.