Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Inheritance guide

Fideicommissary substitutions and fideicomisos in Mallorca: how to leave your assets in two stages

A fideicommissary substitution allows the testator to decide not only who inherits, but also who the assets will pass to afterwards: for example, leaving the family home to the spouse and, on their death, to the children. In Mallorca and Menorca it has its own rules in the Compilation of Balearic Civil Law, more detailed than, and in some respects different from, the Spanish Civil Code. We explain how it works, its limits and the rights of the first heir (fiduciario) and the subsequent heir (fideicomisario).

What a fideicommissary substitution is

It is a provision in a will by which the heir is instructed to preserve and pass on to a third party all or part of the estate (art. 781 of the Civil Code). Three people are involved: the fideicomitente (the testator), the fiduciario (who inherits first and enjoys the assets) and the fideicomisario (who receives them afterwards, usually on the fiduciario's death). In practice it is also called a fideicomiso, but it should not be confused with the common-law trust, which is not an institution of Spanish civil law.

For people with Mallorcan or Menorcan civil status, articles 25 to 37 of the Compilation apply first, and they also govern in Menorca (art. 65); the Civil Code only applies in a supplementary way. In Ibiza and Formentera, fideicomisos are interpreted in accordance with the island legal tradition (art. 78). In addition, the Compilation treats as fideicommissary an appointment of an heir in usufruct followed by the appointment of another heir for after the usufructuary's death, unless the testator intended otherwise (art. 15).

What it is used for in Mallorca

  • Leaving assets to a spouse or partner for life while ensuring they then pass to the children, including in blended families.
  • Keeping a country estate or the family home in the family for two generations.
  • Protecting a child with a disability, with their siblings or nephews and nieces as the ultimate recipients.
  • Arranging successive universal donees in a universal gift, to which these same rules apply (art. 12 of Act 8/2022).

Limits and differences between the Mallorcan Compilation and the Civil Code

IssueMallorca and Menorca (Compilation)Civil Code
Limit on successive callsFamily: up to the second generation, with no limit on number; non-family: two calls; no limit if those called are alive when the testator dies (art. 25)Up to the second degree or in favour of people alive when the testator dies (art. 781)
Fideicomisario who dies before the condition is metPasses no right to their successors, unless the testator provided a substitute within the fideicomiso (art. 27)Acquires from the testator's death and passes the right to their heirs (art. 784)
Ordinary (vulgar) substitutionAlways implied in the fideicommissary one (art. 26)This rule does not appear in articles 781 to 789
Cuarta trebeliánicaYes, with an inventory drawn up in time (art. 29)Does not exist; the fiduciario hands over the estate with deductions only for legitimate expenses, debts and improvements (art. 783)

Under the Civil Code, moreover, a fideicommissary substitution cannot burden the forced share, except where it is established in favour of a child with a disability (arts. 782 and 808), and perpetual prohibitions on sale or substitutions not made expressly have no effect (arts. 783 and 785). If the clause is void, it is treated as not written, but the appointment of the heir remains valid (art. 786). The Compilation adds that children mentioned in a condition are not deemed to be called unless expressly so, with the exception of the double event that the fiduciario dies without children and those children in turn without children (art. 28).

Do you have an inheritance to deal with?

We help you accept or renounce it in time and without tax surprises.

Rights and duties of the fiduciario in Mallorca

  • Use and enjoyment of the assets, with the duty to pay forced shares, legacies and other charges out of the estate (art. 30).
  • Inventory and security for handing the assets over; for real estate, registering their title as fiduciario at the Land Registry is enough. Fiduciarios released by the testator, and children and descendants who are reciprocally substituted, are exempt (art. 30).
  • Debts: if they do not accept with the benefit of inventory, they are liable for the deceased's debts, with a right to be reimbursed from the estate (art. 31).
  • Handover: when the time comes, they or their heirs must hand possession to the fideicomisario within thirty days of being requested (art. 35), but may retain the assets until the accounts are settled and they are reimbursed any balance in their favour and the trebeliánica (art. 36).

The cuarta trebeliánica

It is a quarter of the estate subject to the fideicomiso, after deducting expenses, debts and forced shares. To claim it, the fiduciario must complete a court or notarial inventory within one hundred and eighty days of the estate becoming available, or within one year if the assets are in different municipalities or the fiduciario lives off the island, summoning the known fideicomisarios thirty days in advance or, if there are none, the Public Prosecutor (art. 29). A fiduciary heir can only deduct one quarter in total for falcidia and trebeliánica combined (art. 40).

Can the fiduciario sell inherited assets in Mallorca?

As a rule they must preserve them, but the law allows them to sell or encumber them as if they were free with the consent of the fideicomisarios, to collect their own forced share and the trebeliánica, or to pay debts, charges, cash legacies and extraordinary maintenance costs (art. 33). Otherwise they need court authorisation, with the fideicomisarios summoned, to sell and reinvest the money in more profitable or useful assets, unless the testator prohibited it (art. 34). In Mallorca, that authorisation is sought before the courts of Palma, Inca or Manacor.

If the testator only made subject to the fideicomiso whatever remains with the fiduciario on their death (a residual fideicomiso), the fiduciario may sell or encumber three quarters of the assets for value and must hand over the remaining quarter, unless the testator released them; in case of destitution or extreme need they may also dispose of that quarter (art. 37).

Tax and drafting of a fideicomiso in the Balearic Islands

Inheritance tax is paid on the appointment and on each substitution, according to each beneficiary's relationship with the deceased; the fiduciario is taxed as a usufructuary, unless they can freely dispose of the assets, in which case tax is charged on full ownership (art. 53.3 of the Inheritance Tax Regulations). A poorly drafted clause can create doubts as to whether there is a usufruct, a residual fideicomiso or a pure fideicomiso, with very different effects. That is why it should be designed within the Mallorcan will, the division of the estate should be reviewed when the time comes, and advice sought in our inheritance practice area.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a usufruct and a fideicomiso?

A usufructuary only enjoys the assets; a fiduciario is heir and owner, though bound to preserve and pass them on. In Mallorca, an heir in usufruct with another heir appointed for afterwards is treated as a fiduciario.

How many generations can a fideicomiso last in Mallorca?

If it is a family one, up to the second generation with no limit on calls; otherwise, two calls. There is no limit in favour of people alive when the testator dies.

Can the fiduciario sell the inherited house?

Yes, with the consent of the fideicomisarios, to pay debts and forced shares, with court authorisation or, in a residual fideicomiso, up to three quarters of the assets.

What is the cuarta trebeliánica?

The fiduciario's right to keep a quarter of the estate subject to the fideicomiso, if they draw up a court or notarial inventory in time and the testator did not prohibit it.

Can a fideicomiso protect a child with a disability?

Yes. It makes it possible to secure their support with the assets and decide who will receive them afterwards, combined with any support measures they need.

You may also be interested in