How a labour inspection begins in Mallorca
The Labour and Social Security Inspectorate always acts on its own initiative, but the trigger can vary: a service order under inspection plans or campaigns, a request from another public body, the inspector's own initiative or a complaint (art. 20.3 of Law 23/2015 on the Labour Inspection System). Anyone can file a complaint, but anonymous complaints are not processed (art. 20.5).
The inspection may take the form of a visit to the workplace without prior notice, a summons to appear at the Inspectorate's offices with specified documents, or a check of data already held by the authorities (art. 21). In practice, for a seasonal business in Palma, Calvià, Alcúdia or any tourist area of the island, the visit usually takes place in the middle of trading, with customers and staff present.
Investigations may not last more than nine months, extendable by another nine in complex cases, nor be interrupted for more than five months, unless the delay is attributable to the company (art. 21.4).
What the inspector can do during the visit
Inspectors are public authorities and the law allows them, among other things (art. 13 Law 23/2015):
- To enter the workplace freely, at any time and without prior notice, and to remain there.
- To question the employer or any employee, alone or before witnesses, and to require the people present to identify themselves.
- To examine contracts, payslips, working-time records, registration and contribution documents and health and safety documentation, including computer files.
- To require the employer or managers to appear at the public offices they designate.
An important point in Mallorca, where many country estates and villas employ domestic staff, gardeners or carers: if the place inspected is the home of a private individual, the inspector needs that person's express consent or a court authorisation (art. 13.1).
How your business should behave
Cooperate and stay calm. Preventing the inspector from entering or remaining, refusing to identify those working on the premises or exerting any kind of pressure is a very serious infringement for obstruction (art. 50.4 LISOS), punished with the highest fines on the employment scale. Ask the inspector for official identification, note what is checked and who is interviewed, and do not sign statements you do not understand. If you do not have a document to hand, say so: the inspection will continue through a formal request to provide it later (art. 21.3). This is the moment to call your payroll adviser or your lawyer.
We advise you before the dispute grows.
What is usually checked and the most common infringements
The LISOS classifies infringements as minor, serious and very serious. Among those that most affect small and medium-sized businesses are:
- Failing to register an employee with Social Security before they start work: a serious infringement, counted once for each worker affected (art. 22.2).
- Breaching the rules on working hours, overtime, rest periods, holidays or working-time records: a serious infringement (art. 7.5).
- Using fixed-term contracts fraudulently, again one infringement per person affected (art. 7.2). On the island this often overlaps with the correct use of the permanent seasonal (fijo discontinuo) contract.
- Failing to put the employment contract in writing when required (art. 7.1).
- Non-payment and repeated late payment of wages: a very serious infringement (art. 8.1).
In occupational health and safety, the lack of a risk assessment, training or safety measures may lead not only to a fine but also to an order for the immediate stoppage of work where there is a serious and imminent risk (art. 22.12 Law 23/2015), or to a proposed surcharge on benefits after a workplace accident (art. 22.9).
Amount of LISOS fines
Article 40 of the LISOS sets the fines by degree (minimum, medium and maximum):
| Infringement | Employment relations and Social Security | Occupational health and safety |
|---|---|---|
| Minor | 70 to 750 euros | 45 to 2,450 euros |
| Serious | 751 to 7,500 euros | 2,451 to 49,180 euros |
| Very serious | 7,501 to 225,018 euros | 49,181 to 983,736 euros |
Some amounts are specific: failing to register a worker is punished with a fine of 3,750 to 12,000 euros for each one, increased by between 20% and 50% when several workers are affected in the same inspection (art. 40.1.e). The degree depends on intent, failure to heed previous warnings, turnover, the number of workers affected and the harm caused, and the report must state which criteria were applied (art. 39). Repeat offences within 365 days can double the penalty (art. 41).
Where a Social Security infringement report is accompanied by a contribution assessment report for the same facts, the fine is automatically reduced by 50% if the company accepts the assessment and pays it on time (art. 40.3).
We review it so that there are no surprises.
How to challenge an infringement report in the Balearic Islands
Once the investigation is over, the inspector may simply warn the company and require it to put matters right, without a penalty, if there is no direct harm to workers (art. 22.1 Law 23/2015). If an infringement report is issued, the procedure follows these steps (art. 52 LISOS):
- Service of the report, stating the facts, the infringement, its classification and the proposed fine (art. 53.1).
- Written objections within 15 days to the body that will decide, with evidence that rebuts the facts in the report.
- A further 8-day hearing if facts different from those in the report come to light.
- Decision by the labour authority, which in employment matters is the Government of the Balearic Islands according to its own allocation of powers (art. 48.2).
- Administrative appeal and, once that route is exhausted, a claim before the social (employment) jurisdiction (arts. 2.n and 151 of the Law Regulating the Social Jurisdiction), in the social sections of the Court of First Instance.
Because the facts in the report are presumed true (art. 53.2), objections must be backed by documents: contracts, rotas, working-time records, registration forms, witnesses. Infringements are generally time-barred after three years; in Social Security matters, after four; and in health and safety, after one year for minor, three years for serious and five years for very serious ones (art. 4). If the facts could amount to a criminal offence, the authorities refer them to the court or the public prosecutor and suspend the file (art. 3).
How we help with a labour inspection in Palma
At Castell Abogados we assist businesses throughout Mallorca before, during and after an inspection: we review the documents requested, prepare the appearance, draft objections to the report and, if necessary, challenge the penalty in court. We also help you put contracts and working hours in order so that the next visit is not a problem, as part of our employment law services for businesses.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can a labour inspector turn up without warning?
Yes. The law allows inspectors to enter workplaces at any time and without prior notice. Only if the place is the home of a private individual do they need consent or a court authorisation.
How long do I have to object to an infringement report?
Fifteen days from service of the report. Objections are filed with the body that will decide, together with evidence contradicting the facts recorded by the inspector.
What is the fine for an unregistered worker in Mallorca?
It is a serious infringement punished with a fine of 3,750 to 12,000 euros for each worker affected, with increases if several workers in that situation are found in the same inspection.
What happens if I do not let the inspector in?
Preventing the inspector from entering or remaining in the workplace is a very serious infringement for obstruction, with fines of 7,501 to 225,018 euros.
Can I challenge a labour inspection penalty in the Palma courts?
Yes. After the penalty decision and once the administrative route is exhausted, an employment penalty is challenged before the social jurisdiction, which can review both the facts and the amount of the fine.