When is a misdiagnosis medical negligence?
Diagnosis is an obligation of means: a doctor is not required always to be right, but to act as a diligent professional in their speciality would with the information available at the time. The assessment is made from the perspective of what was known then, not what was learned later. There is usually negligence where:
- No history-taking or examination appropriate to the symptoms was carried out.
- The additional tests indicated by protocols were not ordered.
- They were ordered, but the results were not reviewed or were misinterpreted.
- The patient was discharged from A&E without ruling out serious conditions consistent with the symptoms.
- The follow-up or specialist referral the case required was not made.
The most common cases are delays in diagnosing cancer, missed heart attacks and strokes, appendicitis and meningitis, undetected fractures and errors in prenatal diagnosis.
Loss of chance in delayed diagnosis
It is often impossible to know for certain what would have happened with a timely diagnosis: perhaps the tumour would have been cured, perhaps not. For these cases, case law applies the doctrine of loss of chance: if the delay deprived the patient of a real possibility of more effective treatment or a better prognosis, that lost chance is compensated, in proportion to its probability, and not necessarily the full final harm. The expert report must explain the patient's chances of cure or survival at each point in time.
We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.
Claiming against IB-Salut or a private clinic in Mallorca
| Public healthcare (IB-Salut) | Private healthcare | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | State liability (arts. 32 and 34 of Act 40/2015) | Arts. 1101 and 1902 of the Civil Code |
| Who you claim against | The health authority and, where applicable, its insurer | The doctor, the clinic and their insurers |
| Time limit | One year from recovery or the determination of the extent of after-effects | Five years (contractual) or one year from when you learned of the damage (non-contractual) |
| Procedure | Administrative claim and then judicial review | Mandatory prior negotiation and a civil claim |
In public healthcare, the authority is liable for the normal or abnormal functioning of its services (art. 32.1 of Act 40/2015), but it does not compensate harm that could not have been foreseen or avoided according to the state of scientific knowledge at the time (art. 34.1). The patient claims directly against the authority, which may then turn to its staff if there was intent or gross negligence (art. 36). We coordinate the procedure with our administrative law team.
Proving a misdiagnosis: medical records and expert evidence
- Complete clinical records: A&E reports, history, examination, additional tests and progress notes are part of their minimum content (art. 15 of Act 41/2002). The patient has the right to obtain a copy (art. 18.1).
- Timeline: the dates of each consultation, of the symptoms and of each test. In delayed diagnosis, the time lost is the key to the case.
- Medical expert report from an independent specialist explaining what should have been done, when, and how the delay affected the prognosis.
- Valuation of the harm: days of recovery, after-effects and financial losses. It is common to use the traffic injury scale as a guide.
If the patient died, people linked to them by family or de facto ties can access their records unless the patient expressly prohibited it (art. 18.4 of Act 41/2002), and claim the compensation due to them.
How we handle misdiagnosis claims in Palma and the rest of the Balearic Islands
We obtain the clinical records, build the timeline and put it to an expert in the relevant speciality before claiming. If the expert concludes there was no malpractice, we tell you clearly. In the civil courts, before suing you must try an appropriate dispute resolution method (art. 5 of Organic Act 1/2025); cases are heard by the Courts of First Instance (Tribunales de Instancia) of Palma, Inca or Manacor, and public healthcare cases by the administrative courts. Criminal proceedings for negligent injury are only appropriate for gross or less serious negligence. More information in medical negligence and, if you were also not told about the risks of a test or treatment, in lack of informed consent.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Does every misdiagnosis give a right to compensation?
No. Only where the doctor did not act in line with the lex artis given the information available. A difficult diagnosis that a diligent professional would not have made either is not negligence.
What is loss of chance?
Compensation for the probability of cure or a better prognosis that the delay caused you to lose, where it cannot be proved with certainty that the harm would have been avoided.
How long do I have to claim against IB-Salut in Mallorca?
One year from recovery or from when the extent of the after-effects was determined (art. 67.1 of Act 39/2015).
What if the error happened in a private clinic?
Five years if there was a contract and one year from when you learned of the damage if there was not. A written claim interrupts the period.
Can the family claim if the patient died?
Yes. Relatives can access the clinical records, unless the deceased expressly prohibited it, and claim for the harm the death caused them.