Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Business law guide

Spanish SA or SL company: the legal differences to help you choose well in Mallorca

When setting up a company in Mallorca almost everyone chooses the private limited company (sociedad limitada, SL), but it is not always the best option. The public limited company (sociedad anónima, SA) is still useful when you plan to attract investors, issue debt or make it easy for shareholders to come and go. Both are capital companies and in both the shareholders are not personally liable for the company's debts, but the Spanish Companies Act (LSC) treats them differently in important respects. We review the differences that should weigh in your decision.

What SAs and SLs incorporated in Mallorca have in common

The public limited company (SA) and the private limited company (SL or SRL) are capital companies. In both, the capital is divided into units (shares, or acciones, in the SA; participations, or participaciones, in the SL) and the shareholders are not personally liable for the company's debts (art. 1 LSC). Both acquire legal personality on registration at the Companies Register, in Mallorca the one in Palma, and both have the same basic bodies: the general meeting and the board of directors.

The accounting obligations are also the same: prepare the annual accounts within three months of the year end, approve them at a general meeting and file them. We explain this in our guide on annual accounts. The liability of those who run the company follows the same rules in both, as we explain in directors' liability.

Differences between an SA and an SL: comparison table

AspectPrivate limited company (SL)Public limited company (SA)
Minimum capital1 euro (special rules below 3,000 euros)60,000 euros
Initial paymentIn fullAt least 25% of each share
Units of capitalParticipations, which are not securitiesShares, which are transferable securities
TransferRestricted and by public documentFree unless restricted by the bylaws
Notice of general meetingAt least 15 daysAt least one month
Director's term of officeIndefinite, unless the bylaws set a termMaximum six years, renewable
Board of directorsBetween 3 and 12 membersAt least 3 members
Is there a problem in your business?

We advise you before the dispute grows.

Capital and paying up: what the Companies Act requires

Private limited company

The capital of an SL cannot be less than one euro. Until it reaches 3,000 euros, at least 20% of profits must go to the legal reserve until reserve and capital together reach that figure, and if the company is wound up without sufficient assets, the shareholders are jointly and severally liable for the difference between 3,000 euros and the subscribed capital (art. 4.1 LSC). The participations must be fully taken up and paid up when the deed is executed (art. 78 LSC).

Public limited company

An SA needs a minimum capital of 60,000 euros (art. 4.2 LSC). The shares must be fully subscribed, but only a quarter of the nominal value of each needs to be paid up on incorporation (art. 79 LSC). The rest is contributed in the manner and by the deadline set by the bylaws, and calls must be notified or published in the Official Gazette of the Companies Register at least one month in advance (art. 81 LSC).

Shareholders coming and going: shares and participations

This is probably the fundamental difference. The SL is designed as a closed company; the SA as an open one.

  • Nature: shares can be represented by certificates or book entries and are transferable securities; participations cannot be represented in that way, cannot be called shares and are never securities (art. 92 LSC).
  • Transfer in an SL: it is free between shareholders and to the spouse, ascendants, descendants or group companies; in other cases, unless the bylaws provide otherwise, it requires the consent of the general meeting, which can only refuse if it puts forward another buyer (art. 107 LSC). It must be made by public document (art. 106 LSC).
  • Transfer in an SA: restrictions are only valid if they apply to registered shares and appear in the bylaws; restrictions making the share practically non-transferable are void, and where company authorisation is required it is deemed granted after two months without reply (art. 123 LSC).

For a family business or a venture between a few partners in Palma, the SL gives better protection against outsiders coming in. If a funding round or future partial sale is expected, the SA may be more convenient. In family businesses, these rules are complemented by the family protocol.

Are you about to sign an important contract?

We review it so that there are no surprises.

General meetings, majorities and management in the SA and the SL

In the SL, resolutions are passed by a majority of the votes validly cast, provided they represent at least one third of the votes attached to the capital (art. 198 LSC); amendments to the bylaws require more than half of the votes of the capital, and operations such as conversion, merger or the exclusion of shareholders at least two thirds (art. 199 LSC). In the SA, by contrast, the law requires a quorum of 25% on first call (art. 193 LSC), higher for amendments to the bylaws (art. 194 LSC), and resolutions are passed by a simple majority of the capital present or represented (art. 201 LSC).

As to management, in the SL directors hold office indefinitely unless the bylaws set a term (art. 221.1 LSC), whereas in the SA the term cannot exceed six years (art. 221.2 LSC). In the SA, if joint management is entrusted to more than two people they must form a board (art. 210.2 LSC); in the SL the board cannot exceed twelve members (art. 242.2 LSC).

Which suits your business in Mallorca?

For most businesses on the island, such as restaurants, service companies, estate agencies or building and renovation firms, the SL is sufficient and simpler. The SA makes sense when the project needs substantial capital, ownership is meant to change hands easily or financing through bond issues is planned. Before deciding, consider too whether trading as a sole trader is enough: we compare the two in sole trader or limited company. We can help you with forming your company and with bylaws suited to your case from our office in Palma.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Can I convert an SL into an SA later?

Yes. Conversion is a structural change that requires a general meeting resolution with a reinforced majority and, for the SA, reaching the minimum capital of 60,000 euros.

Does an SA protect personal assets more than an SL?

No. In both, shareholders are not personally liable for the company's debts. The difference lies in capital, transfer of ownership and how the corporate bodies work.

Which form do most businesses in Mallorca choose?

The private limited company, because of its lower minimum capital and simplicity. The public limited company is kept for projects with more capital or where investors are expected to come in.

Can I sell my SL participations to anyone?

Only freely to other shareholders, your spouse, ascendants, descendants or group companies. In other cases the bylaws apply and, failing them, the general meeting consent required by law.

How long does a director's term last?

In the SL, indefinitely unless the bylaws set a term. In the SA, the term set by the bylaws, which cannot exceed six years, with the possibility of re-election.

You may also be interested in