What a shareholders' agreement is and its legal value
A shareholders' agreement, also known as a side or parasocial agreement, is a private agreement between all or some of a company's partners that governs their relationship beyond the articles of association. It rests on the freedom of contract in article 1255 of the Civil Code: the parties may agree whatever terms they consider appropriate provided they are not contrary to the law, morality or public order. And what has been agreed has the force of law between the parties (art. 1091 Civil Code).
Its main limitation lies in article 29 of the Capital Companies Act: agreements kept confidential between the partners cannot be enforced against the company. In practice, if a partner breaches the agreement, the others can sue that partner, but a resolution of the general meeting or a transfer contrary to the agreement is not automatically invalid as against the company. Moreover, the contract only binds those who sign it and their heirs (art. 1257 Civil Code), not a new partner who does not accede to it.
Key clauses in a shareholders' agreement
| Clause | What it is for |
|---|---|
| Lock-up | Prevents the sale of shares for a period, to secure the founders' commitment |
| Tag-along | If a partner sells, the minority partners can sell to the same buyer on the same terms |
| Drag-along | If an offer is received for the whole company, the majority can require the others to sell |
| Right of first refusal | The partners have priority to buy the shares of the one who wants to leave |
| Departure of a working partner (good/bad leaver) | Sets the price at which shares are bought back if a partner stops working in the business |
| Deadlock | Mechanisms to break a tie: mediation, an expert, cross purchase offers |
| Non-compete and confidentiality | Protect the business against a partner who leaves it |
Corporate governance and qualified majorities
The agreement can require unanimity or a qualified majority for important decisions: significant borrowing, sale of assets, admission of partners, appointment of directors or distribution of dividends. It can also give each group of partners the right to nominate a director, which is particularly useful in family companies.
Dividend policy
The law already grants a right to withdraw where, after the fifth financial year since the company was registered, the general meeting does not distribute at least 25% of the previous year's distributable profits and the partner has recorded their protest (art. 348 bis of the Capital Companies Act), unless the articles provide otherwise. The agreement can set out a clearer dividend policy to avoid disputes.
We advise you before the dispute grows.
Shareholders' agreement and articles of association: how to coordinate them
Because confidential agreements cannot be enforced against the company, it is advisable to transfer to the articles the clauses that can be included there. Article 28 of the Capital Companies Act allows the articles to contain any terms the partners consider appropriate, provided they do not conflict with the law or the principles of the type of company. There are specific limits:
- Clauses in the articles that make the transfer of shares practically free are void (art. 108.1 Capital Companies Act).
- A prohibition on transfer is only valid if the partner is given a right to withdraw at any time, although the articles may prevent transfer or withdrawal for up to five years from incorporation or from a capital increase (art. 108.3 and 4 Capital Companies Act).
- Ancillary obligations (prestaciones accesorias) make it possible to attach obligations such as working in the business or not competing to the status of partner, with a penalty clause (art. 86 Capital Companies Act).
A good design combines articles and agreement: the articles for what must bind the company and third parties, and the agreement for confidential matters or what the law does not allow to be registered. You can see how to plan the initial structure in our guide to setting up a company.
What happens if a partner breaches the agreement in Mallorca
A breach is enforced like any contract: specific performance, damages or, if agreed, the penalty clause. The penalty replaces damages unless otherwise agreed (art. 1152 Civil Code), which avoids having to prove the loss. That is why we recommend setting proportionate and clear penalties.
It is also wise to provide for how disputes will be resolved: prior mediation, arbitration or the relevant courts in Mallorca (Palma, Inca or Manacor). A badly handled partners' dispute can end in the dissolution of the company or in claims based on directors' liability.
When to sign a shareholders' agreement in the Balearic Islands
- When setting up the company, while all partners agree and negotiation is easier.
- When an investor or new partner joins, often through a capital increase.
- In Mallorca family businesses, to organise the entry of the next generation.
- Before selling all or part of the business, to set the rules of the transaction; see our guide to the business sale agreement.
We draft shareholders' agreements in English, German and Spanish, which is common in Mallorca companies with foreign partners.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Is a shareholders' agreement compulsory?
No. It is voluntary, but highly advisable where there are several partners, investors or partners who work in the business.
Is the shareholders' agreement registered at the Companies Registry?
The agreement as such is not registered and, if confidential, cannot be enforced against the company. Clauses intended to bind the company and third parties must be written into the articles.
Does the shareholders' agreement bind a new partner who joins later?
Only if they accede to it. That is why the agreement itself usually requires any buyer of shares to sign it.
What is a drag-along clause?
It allows the majority to require the minority partners to sell their shares to the same buyer on the same terms when an offer is received for the whole company.
Where is a breach of a shareholders' agreement litigated in Mallorca?
Before the court or arbitration agreed; failing that, before the competent Court of First Instance in Mallorca, after attempting an appropriate dispute resolution method.