Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Claims guide

Trips and falls on public streets in Mallorca: how to claim compensation from the council

A raised paving stone, an unmarked pothole or a sunken manhole cover can cause a fall with serious injuries. Where the harm is due to the poor condition of the street, the town council may have to pay compensation under the system of public authority liability. We explain the requirements, the one-year time limit and how to prepare a claim that succeeds.

Who is liable for a fall in the street

Paving and maintaining urban public streets is a municipal responsibility (arts. 25.2 and 26.1 of Law 7/1985 on the Bases of Local Government), and local authorities are directly liable for harm caused by the functioning of their public services (art. 54 of the same law). That is why, for a fall on a pavement or street in a town centre, the claim is normally addressed to the town council (Ayuntamiento).

There are important nuances:

  • If the fall happens on a road or through-road that is not municipal, the authority that owns the road is liable; in Mallorca this may be the Consell de Mallorca.
  • Even if private parties contributed to the harm or the council has liability insurance, the claim against the authority goes through the administrative procedure and the administrative courts, not the civil courts (art. 2.e of the Administrative Jurisdiction Act).
  • Where several authorities are involved, liability is divided according to their responsibilities and, if that cannot be determined, it is joint and several (art. 33.2).

Requirements for the council to pay compensation for a fall

Public authority liability is strict: you do not need to prove that an official was at fault. But the following elements must be present (art. 32 of Law 40/2015):

  1. Real harm, assessable in money and individualised: injuries, days off work, after-effects, medical costs, broken clothing or glasses.
  2. A causal link between the functioning of the service (the poor condition of the street) and the fall.
  3. No legal duty to bear the harm and no force majeure.

The key issue: the standard of maintenance

In practice, most claims are argued over causation. The courts consider whether the defect was significant and went beyond what a pedestrian can reasonably expect in a town, whether it was signposted, whether it was visible, the lighting conditions and the care the pedestrian should have taken. A small unevenness in the pavement, in broad daylight and in an area the pedestrian knew, is usually treated as a risk one must bear. A deep, unmarked pothole or a loose manhole cover is not. If the victim was careless, compensation may be reduced.

Do you think you have been overcharged?

We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.

The evidence of your fall you should gather

The burden of proof lies with the claimant, and the evidence should be prepared from the very day of the fall:

  • Photographs of the defect, with an object that shows its size and depth, and of the area in general (signs, lighting).
  • Witnesses: names and phone numbers of those who saw the fall.
  • Attendance by the local police or an ambulance, if any: their report is very valuable evidence.
  • The A&E report from the same day and all subsequent medical follow-up.
  • Expenses: invoices for physiotherapy, pharmacy, travel and damaged items.

It is advisable to photograph the spot again a few days later: if the council repairs the defect shortly after the fall, that fact may also be relevant.

What is the time limit to claim from Palma or your local council?

StageTime limit or ruleLegal basis
Filing the claimOne year from the fall or, for injuries, from recovery or stabilisation of after-effectsArt. 67.1 Law 39/2015
Report from the department concernedMandatory, within ten daysArt. 81.1 Law 39/2015
DecisionIf no decision is notified within six months, the claim is deemed rejectedArt. 91.3 Law 39/2015
Court appealBefore the administrative courtsArt. 2.e Administrative Jurisdiction Act

What the claim must contain

The claim must specify the injuries suffered, the causal link with the functioning of the service, the economic assessment of the harm where possible and when it occurred, and must be accompanied by documents and proposed evidence (art. 67.2 of Law 39/2015). To value the injuries, the road traffic compensation scale may be used as a reference (art. 34.2 of Law 40/2015), the same one used in road traffic accidents. The amount is updated to the date of the decision and bears interest if paid late (art. 34.3).

If there is an express decision rejecting the claim, the appeal to the administrative courts must be lodged within two months (art. 46.1 of the Administrative Jurisdiction Act); an optional request for reconsideration (recurso de reposición) can also be filed within one month. In Mallorca, the appeal is lodged with the administrative section of the Palma Court of First Instance or, depending on the case, with the High Court of Justice of the Balearic Islands. As these are administrative proceedings, the civil-law requirement to attempt an appropriate dispute resolution method first does not apply.

When a lawyer is worth it for a fall claim in Mallorca

You can file the administrative claim yourself, but the way it is first framed shapes the whole procedure: a poor description of the location, insufficient photos or an incomplete assessment of after-effects are hard to correct later. Advice is especially useful where there are fractures, surgery or permanent after-effects, or where the victim is a tourist who has already returned home. In our administrative law and claims practice we handle the file from the first letter through to trial if necessary.

If the injury was made worse by poor medical care afterwards, there may also be a claim for medical negligence, which has its own rules.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to claim against the council for a fall?

One year. For physical injuries, the time limit runs from recovery or from when the extent of the after-effects is determined (art. 67.1 of Law 39/2015).

Do I have to prove the council was at fault?

You do not need to prove fault, because liability is strict. But you must prove the harm, that it was caused by the poor condition of the street and that it was not a risk you were expected to bear.

What happens if the council does not reply?

If no decision is notified within six months, you can treat the claim as rejected and go to the administrative courts.

How is compensation calculated?

The road traffic compensation scale can be used as a reference for the injuries, plus documented expenses. The amount is updated to the date of the decision.

Can I claim if I fell because I was not looking where I was going?

If your carelessness contributed to the fall, compensation may be reduced or, if the defect was minimal and visible, the claim may be rejected. Each case is assessed on its own facts.

You may also be interested in