Which general meeting resolutions can be challenged?
Article 204 of the Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital, LSC) sets out three main grounds of challenge, which apply to both private limited companies (SL) and public limited companies (SA):
- Resolutions contrary to the law: for example, a dividend paid without distributable profits or an amendment to the articles approved without the statutory majority.
- Resolutions that breach the articles of association or the rules of the general meeting.
- Resolutions that harm the company's interest for the benefit of one or more shareholders or third parties. The law states that there is also harm when the resolution, without damaging the company's assets, is imposed abusively: without meeting any reasonable need of the company, the majority adopts it in its own interest and to the unjustified detriment of the other shareholders.
This last situation is common in family companies in Mallorca: disproportionate pay for directors who control the majority, capital increases designed to dilute a shareholder or a systematic refusal to distribute profits. If the resolution has already been validly revoked or replaced before the claim is filed, the challenge is not admissible (art. 204.2).
Defects that are not enough on their own
To avoid litigation over minor issues, article 204.3 rules out challenges based on:
- Merely procedural breaches, unless they concern the form and notice period of the call, the essential rules for constituting the meeting, the required majorities or any other relevant matter.
- Incorrect or insufficient information given before the meeting, unless it was essential for the average shareholder to exercise their vote reasonably.
- The attendance of persons not entitled to attend, unless this was decisive for the meeting to be validly constituted.
- Invalid votes or counting errors, unless they were decisive in reaching the required majority.
In addition, anyone who could have raised a formal defect at the meeting itself and failed to do so cannot rely on it later (art. 206.5). That is why it pays to attend the meeting with legal advice and to have every objection recorded in the minutes.
Time limit for challenging company resolutions: one year
The action to challenge lapses after one year (art. 205 LSC). Time runs from the date of the meeting; if the resolution was adopted in writing, from receipt of the copy of the minutes; and if it was registered at the Companies Register, from the date on which the registration becomes enforceable against third parties. As this is a limitation period that cannot simply be interrupted, a mere letter of complaint does not stop the clock.
The exception is resolutions contrary to public policy, which by their cause, content or circumstances affect essential principles of the legal order: against these the action never lapses, and it may be brought by any shareholder, even one who joined the company later, any director or any third party (arts. 205.1 and 206.2).
We advise you before the dispute grows.
Who can bring the challenge and against whom
| Entitled party | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Shareholders | Must have been shareholders before the resolution and hold, alone or together, at least 1% of the capital (the articles may lower this) |
| Directors | Any of them |
| Third parties | Must show a legitimate interest |
| Any shareholder, director or third party | Only if the resolution is contrary to public policy |
A shareholder who does not reach the threshold is not left without protection: they can claim compensation for the damage the resolution has caused them (art. 206.1). The claim is always brought against the company, and shareholders who voted in favour may join the proceedings at their own expense to defend the resolution (art. 206.3 and 4).
How the challenge is handled by the courts in Palma
Challenges follow the procedure of ordinary proceedings (art. 207.1 LSC and art. 249.1.3 LEC). Jurisdiction lies with the court of the place of the registered office (art. 52.1.10 LEC) and, under the Judiciary Act, with the commercial judge: for companies registered in Mallorca, the Commercial Section of the Palma Court of First Instance (Tribunal de Instancia).
- Prior attempt to settle. Under Organic Law 1/2025, before suing you must, as a general rule, attempt an appropriate dispute resolution method (art. 5). The request to negotiate suspends the limitation period from the date on which the attempt to notify the company is recorded (art. 7), but the timing must be calculated carefully.
- Interim measures. You can ask for the challenged resolution to be suspended if the claimants hold at least 5% of the capital, or 1% in listed companies (art. 727.10 LEC).
- Remedying the defect. If the ground of challenge can be removed, the judge will, at the company's request, give it a reasonable period to remedy it (art. 207.2 LSC).
Effects of the judgment and how we help you in Mallorca
A final judgment annulling a resolution that can be registered is entered in the Companies Register and an extract is published in the Official Gazette of the Companies Register (BORME); if the resolution was already registered, its entry and any later contradictory entries are cancelled (art. 208 LSC).
At Castell Abogados we review the notice of meeting, the minutes and the meeting documents, calculate the deadline and assess whether the resolution can really be challenged or whether another route is better: the shareholder's withdrawal, a directors' liability claim or, in the most serious cases, a criminal complaint for corporate offences. You can read about our general approach under companies and commercial law.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to challenge a general meeting resolution?
One year from the date of the meeting, or from when its registration becomes enforceable if the resolution was entered in the Companies Register. If the resolution is contrary to public policy, the action never lapses.
Can I challenge a resolution if I hold less than 1% of the capital?
You can join forces with other shareholders to reach that threshold, unless the articles set a lower one. If you do not reach it, you keep the right to claim compensation for the damage the resolution causes you.
What is an abusive resolution?
One that the majority adopts in its own interest and to the unjustified detriment of the other shareholders, without meeting any reasonable need of the company. It is considered harmful to the company's interest even if it does not damage the company's assets.
Is the resolution suspended while the case is pending in Palma?
Not automatically. Suspension must be requested as an interim measure, and only claimants holding at least 5% of the capital, or 1% if the company is listed, may apply for it.
Do I have to try to settle before suing?
As a general rule, yes: since Organic Law 1/2025, an appropriate dispute resolution method, such as a negotiation between lawyers or mediation, must be attempted before bringing civil proceedings.