Shareholder withdrawal: when you can leave the company
In a private limited company (SL), a shareholder cannot simply "resign". To leave, they normally sell their shares to another shareholder or to a third party, subject to the limits in the articles or the law (art. 107 LSC). Withdrawal is the way out even when nobody buys, and it is only available in the cases provided for by law or by the articles:
- Replacement or substantial change of the corporate purpose.
- Extension of the company's duration.
- Reactivation of a dissolved company.
- Creation, amendment or early termination of the obligation to perform ancillary obligations, unless the articles provide otherwise.
- In a private limited company, a change to the rules on transferring shares.
Only shareholders who did not vote in favour of the resolution may withdraw, including holders of non-voting shares (art. 346.1). For structural changes (mergers, demergers, conversions), the specific rules of Royal Decree-Law 5/2023 apply (art. 346.3). The articles may add further grounds, but introducing, amending or removing them requires the consent of all shareholders (art. 347). Moreover, if the articles prohibit the sale of shares, that clause is only valid if they give shareholders the right to withdraw at any time (art. 108.3).
Withdrawal for failure to distribute dividends
Article 348 bis allows a shareholder to withdraw, unless the articles provide otherwise, if they recorded their objection in the minutes when, after the fifth financial year since the company's registration and with profits in the three previous years, the general meeting does not resolve to distribute at least 25% of the previous year's distributable profits. The right does not arise if at least 25% of the distributable profits for the last five years has been paid out over that period. The deadline is one month from the annual general meeting. It is a key tool for a minority shareholder in a Mallorcan family business who sees profits always kept inside the company.
How to exercise the right of withdrawal in a Mallorca company
Resolutions giving rise to a right of withdrawal are published in the Official Gazette of the Companies Register (BORME), although in a private limited company the directors may replace publication with a written notice to each shareholder who did not vote in favour (art. 348.1). From publication or receipt of the notice, the shareholder has one month to exercise the right in writing (art. 348.2). We recommend doing so in a verifiable way, by burofax or notarial notice. To register the resolution, the directors must declare that nobody has withdrawn or that the company has acquired the shares or reduced its capital (art. 349).
We advise you before the dispute grows.
Expelling a shareholder: grounds and procedure
Expulsion is the removal of a shareholder by decision of the company. In a private limited company, the law allows it in these cases (art. 350):
- A shareholder who wilfully fails to perform ancillary obligations.
- A shareholder-director who breaches the non-compete prohibition.
- A shareholder-director ordered by final judgment to compensate the company for acts contrary to the law or the articles or carried out without due diligence.
The articles may provide for other specific grounds, with the consent of all shareholders (art. 351). Expulsion requires a resolution of the general meeting (art. 352.1), which in a private limited company needs at least two-thirds of the votes attached to the shares (art. 199.b), and the shareholder concerned may not vote (art. 190.1). If the shareholder holds 25% or more of the capital and does not accept the expulsion, a final court judgment is also required, except where they were ordered to compensate the company as a director (art. 352.2). If the company does not sue within one month, any shareholder who voted in favour may do so (art. 352.3).
Valuation and repayment of the departing shareholder's shares
| Step | Time limit or rule | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement on fair value or on who calculates it | Freely agreed between company and shareholder | Art. 353.1 LSC |
| No agreement: independent expert | Appointed by the Companies Registrar of the registered office | Art. 353.1 LSC |
| Expert's report | Within two months of appointment | Art. 354.2 LSC |
| Payment or deposit | Two months from receipt of the report | Art. 356 LSC |
The expert's fees are paid by the company, although in the case of expulsion it may deduct from the expelled shareholder a share proportional to their holding (art. 355). If creditors have a right to object, repayment is delayed (art. 356.3). The directors then execute a deed reducing the capital or acquiring the shares, without a new resolution or the shareholder's signature (arts. 358 and 359). In Mallorca, the expert is appointed by the Palma Companies Register where the company's registered office is on the island.
How we help you in Palma to leave a company or remove a shareholder
An exit is often best resolved through negotiation and a well-drafted share purchase agreement. Where there is no agreement, we analyse the articles, the shareholders' agreement and the minutes, prepare the withdrawal notice or the expulsion resolution and, if the meeting adopts resolutions against your rights, consider a challenge to company resolutions. Where the conflict paralyses the business, dissolving the company may also be an option. More information under companies.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I leave a private limited company whenever I want?
Not as a general rule. You can sell your shares in line with the articles, or withdraw if there is a legal or statutory ground. Only if the articles prohibit sales do you have the right to withdraw at any time.
How long do I have to exercise the right of withdrawal?
One month from publication of the resolution in the BORME or from receipt of the directors' written notice. For withdrawal due to lack of dividends, one month from the annual general meeting.
Who decides how much my shares are worth?
First, an agreement with the company is attempted. Failing that, an independent expert appointed by the Companies Registrar of the registered office, in Mallorca the Palma registrar, sets their fair value.
Can the majority expel me without going to court?
If you hold less than 25% of the capital, a general meeting resolution is enough, although you can challenge it. If you hold 25% or more and do not accept it, the company needs a final judgment, unless you were ordered to compensate it as a director.
When does the departing shareholder get paid?
Within two months of receiving the valuation report; if they do not collect it, the directors deposit the amount in their name with a credit institution. If creditors can object, payment is delayed.