What a community service sentence is
Article 49 of the Criminal Code defines this penalty as the obligation to provide unpaid cooperation in activities of public benefit. Where they are related to offences of a similar nature to the one committed, those activities may consist of repairing the damage caused or supporting or assisting victims. The penalty may also be served by taking part in workshops or training programmes on re-education, employment, culture, road safety, sexual education, peaceful conflict resolution, positive parenting and similar subjects.
The law sets minimum conditions: the work must not undermine the dignity of the convicted person, it is provided by the authorities (which may sign agreements with public or private bodies), it must not pursue economic interests and the convicted person enjoys the social security protection provided for prisoners.
The offender's consent is essential
This penalty cannot be imposed without the consent of the convicted person. For this reason, where an offence is punishable by prison, a fine or community service as alternatives, the defence often negotiates this option as part of a plea agreement, for example in a fast-track trial. If the defendant does not accept it, the judge must choose one of the other penalties provided for.
When the Mallorca courts impose it
Community service can result from a conviction in several ways:
- As the penalty laid down for the offence itself, usually as an alternative to prison or a fine. This is the case with driving well over the speed limit or under the influence of alcohol (art. 379 of the Criminal Code, 31 to 90 days), driving without a licence (art. 384, 31 to 90 days) or occasional abuse within a couple (art. 153.1, 31 to 80 days).
- As a substitute for a prison term of less than three months: where the calculation of the penalty results in such a short prison term, it is replaced by a fine, community service or home detention, at the rate of one working day for each day of prison (art. 71.2).
- To serve an unpaid fine: if the convicted person does not pay the fine, they become liable to one day's deprivation of liberty for every two unpaid daily instalments, which the judge may, with their agreement, allow to be served through community service (one day equals one working day; art. 53).
- As a condition for suspending a prison sentence: the judge may make the suspension of the sentence conditional on community service, up to one day of work for each day of prison, calculated on two thirds of its length (art. 84.1.3).
| Length | Type of penalty | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| 1 to 30 days | Minor | Art. 33.4 Criminal Code |
| 31 days to 1 year | Less serious | Art. 33.3 Criminal Code |
| Daily working day | Maximum 8 hours (art. 49 Criminal Code) | |
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
How it is served in Mallorca, step by step
Royal Decree 840/2011 governs how the penalty is carried out. Once the judgment is final, the court sends the order to the services for the management of alternative penalties and measures where the convicted person lives. In Mallorca, this means the penalty is managed on the island even if the sentence was handed down elsewhere in Spain.
- Summons and interview: the services summon the convicted person and warn them of the consequences of not attending. If they fail to attend without justification, the services inform the court enforcing the judgment (art. 5.2 of Royal Decree 840/2011).
- Choice of placement: they are told about the available placements, with their tasks and hours, and their own proposal is heard. The convicted person may propose a specific job, which the authorities will assess (arts. 4.3 and 5.1).
- Execution plan: a plan is drawn up which is enforceable from the outset and is sent to the prison supervision court. If the convicted person demonstrably objects, the judge is informed (art. 5.3).
- Serving the penalty: family and work commitments are taken into account when setting the working days. A principle of flexibility applies which, where there is good reason, allows the working day to be split within the same day or across different days (art. 6).
- Final report: once the plan is completed, the prison supervision judge and the court enforcing the judgment are notified (art. 9).
On the days actually worked, the convicted person is covered against workplace accidents and occupational diseases, except when serving the penalty through workshops or training programmes (art. 11 of Royal Decree 840/2011).
What happens if it is not completed?
The prison social services must report any relevant incidents to the prison supervision judge and, in any event, if the convicted person:
- Is absent from work for at least two working days, where this amounts to a voluntary refusal to serve the penalty.
- Performs significantly below the minimum required despite warnings from the person in charge.
- Repeatedly and clearly opposes or disregards the instructions given.
- Behaves in such a way that the person in charge refuses to keep them at the workplace.
After assessing the report, the judge may order the person to continue at the same placement, send them to another one or find that they have breached the penalty. In the latter case, the matter is referred for a possible offence of breach of sentence, which for someone who is not in custody is punishable by a fine of 12 to 24 months (art. 468.1 of the Criminal Code). Absences for good reason are not treated as abandonment, but those days do not count and must be made up (art. 49.7 of the Criminal Code).
If the community service was a condition of a suspended sentence, a serious or repeated breach may lead to the suspension being revoked and the suspended prison term being enforced (art. 86.1.c). It is therefore advisable always to justify any absence and, if there are problems with the schedule, to request a change to the plan in good time.
Criminal record and other effects
Community service is a penalty and therefore results in a criminal record. Once it has been served, the period for having the criminal record expunged is six months if the penalty was minor and two years if it did not exceed twelve months (art. 136.1 of the Criminal Code). In traffic offences such as drink-driving, it is usually accompanied by disqualification from driving, which is a separate penalty and is served separately.
At Castell Abogados we advise residents and visitors in Mallorca both on negotiating the penalty and on problems with its enforcement before the courts in Palma, Inca and Manacor. We work in Spanish, Mallorcan, English and German on 684 450 450.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I be forced to do community service?
No. Article 49 of the Criminal Code requires the convicted person's consent. If you do not give it, the judge will impose one of the other penalties provided for the offence.
How many hours is each working day?
Eight hours a day at most. The execution plan takes into account your job and family responsibilities, and the working day can be split where there is good reason.
Can I choose where to do the work?
The services for the management of penalties will offer you the available placements and listen to your proposal. You can also propose a specific job, which the authorities will assess.
What happens if I miss a day because I am ill?
If the absence is justified it is not treated as abandonment, but that day does not count and you will have to make it up. Always provide proof of the reason.
Can I pay off a fine with community service?
If you do not pay the fine, the judge may agree, with your consent, that the default liability be served through community service, at the rate of one working day for each day of deprivation of liberty.