The principle: only when the law says so
Article 12 of the Criminal Code establishes that negligent acts or omissions are only punished when the law expressly provides for it. That is why, for example, there is no such thing as negligent theft or negligent fraud: if there is no intent, there is no offence. On the other hand, the Code provides for a negligent form in offences such as:
- Negligent homicide (art. 142).
- Negligent injury (art. 152).
- Damage caused by serious negligence exceeding 80,000 euros (art. 267).
- Fires caused by serious negligence (art. 358).
- Money laundering through serious negligence (art. 301.3).
- Offences against the environment, against workers' safety and some offences of creating a risk.
Degrees of negligence
| Degree | What it is | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Serious | Omitting the most basic precautions that any person would take in that situation | An offence carrying prison sentences in the most serious cases |
| Less serious | A significant lack of care, but of intermediate significance | An offence punished with a fine, usually only prosecuted upon a complaint |
| Minor | A lesser degree of carelessness | Not an offence; civil liability only |
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
Negligence on the road
Since the 2019 reform, the Criminal Code specifies the degrees of negligence in road traffic:
- Driving in which the influence of alcohol or drugs, or a criminal speed, has determined the result is always serious negligence.
- Less serious negligence is negligence not classified as serious in which a serious breach of the traffic rules was decisive.
We explain this under road traffic offences.
Professional negligence
When negligence is committed in the exercise of a profession (doctors, architects, professional drivers), the Criminal Code adds professional disqualification. Something more is required: a breach of the rules of the profession that any diligent professional would know.
How it is assessed
The courts analyse the foreseeability of the result, the duty of care that was breached, the link between the breach and the result, and the degree of the breach. The defence works to show that the result was unforeseeable, that the required precautions were taken or that the negligence was minor. When the person makes an unintentional mistake about the facts, a mistake of fact may also come into play.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Is an accident always an offence?
No. It is only an offence if there was serious or less serious negligence and the offence can be committed negligently. Minor negligence only gives rise to civil liability.
What is the difference between serious and less serious negligence?
Serious negligence consists of omitting the most basic precautions. Less serious negligence is an intermediate lack of care. The former carries heavier penalties, including imprisonment.
Is there such a thing as negligent robbery or fraud?
No. Only the forms of negligence expressly provided for by law are punished, and these offences always require intent.
Is a complaint required for negligent offences?
For less serious negligence, generally yes: such offences are only prosecuted upon a complaint by the injured party. Offences of serious negligence are prosecuted ex officio.
What is professional negligence?
Negligence committed in the exercise of a profession by breaching its basic rules. It also carries disqualification from practising that profession.