Intent and mistake
Most offences require intent (dolo): knowing what you are doing and wanting to do it. If the person is unaware of some element of the offence, they are not acting with intent. Article 14 of the Criminal Code addresses this and distinguishes between two kinds of mistake.
Mistake of fact
This is a mistake about one of the facts that make up the offence. For example:
- Taking someone else's coat in the belief that it is your own.
- Buying an object without knowing, or being able to suspect, that it is stolen, in which case there is no handling of stolen goods.
- Having sexual relations with a person under 16 in the well-founded belief that they were older.
| Mistake of fact | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Unavoidable: anyone in that situation would have made the mistake | Excludes criminal liability |
| Avoidable: it could have been avoided with greater care | Punished as a negligent offence, if the law provides for a negligent form; if not, there is no offence |
| About an aggravating circumstance or a fact that qualifies the offence | Prevents the aggravation from being applied |
As many offences have no negligent form (theft, for example), an avoidable mistake about their elements leads to acquittal. We explain this under criminal negligence.
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
Mistake of law
This is a mistake about the unlawfulness of the conduct: the person knows what they are doing but believes it is permitted. For example, someone who believes that an administrative authorisation they hold allows them to carry out an activity that is in fact criminal, or a newly arrived foreigner who does not know that conduct permitted in their own country is an offence in Spain.
| Mistake of law | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Unavoidable | Excludes criminal liability |
| Avoidable | Penalty reduced by one or two degrees |
The courts are demanding: it is not enough to claim that you did not know the law. They consider the person's education, their circumstances, whether the conduct is clearly unlawful to anyone and whether they had the opportunity to find out. For obviously reprehensible conduct, such as assaulting or robbing someone, a mistake of law is not accepted.
How it is proved
It is for the defence to provide the information that makes the mistake credible: documents, communications, prior advice, personal circumstances. At the same time, the prosecution must prove intent, under the presumption of innocence. In practice, mistake is frequently raised in financial, planning, intellectual property and immigration offences, where the boundary between lawful and unlawful is technical.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I argue that I didn't know it was an offence?
Yes, as a mistake of law, but the courts only accept it if the mistake was reasonable in your circumstances. If it was avoidable, it reduces the penalty; if it was unavoidable, it excludes liability.
What is the difference between a mistake of fact and a mistake of law?
A mistake of fact concerns the facts: you do not know what you are doing. A mistake of law concerns the law: you know what you are doing but believe it is permitted.
What is an avoidable mistake?
One that could have been avoided by acting with due care, for example by finding out before acting.
Is there an offence if I am mistaken about a minor's age?
If the mistake about age was unavoidable, there is no intentional offence. If it was avoidable, there would only be an offence if a negligent form exists, and none is provided for sexual offences.
Does being a foreigner allow me to claim ignorance of the law?
It may be a relevant factor in assessing a mistake of law, but it is not enough on its own, especially for conduct that is clearly unlawful in any country.