What a defective product is and how it differs from the guarantee
The defective product liability regime is in articles 128 to 146 of the consolidated text of the General Consumer and User Protection Act, approved by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007. For these purposes, a product is any movable item, even when attached to or incorporated into another movable or immovable item, as well as gas and electricity (art. 136).
A product is defective when it does not provide the safety that could legitimately be expected, taking into account its presentation, its reasonably foreseeable use and the time it was put into circulation (art. 137.1). It is not defective merely because an improved version is later placed on the market (art. 137.3).
Do not confuse it with the legal guarantee on products. The guarantee protects you against a product that does not work or does not match what was agreed, and is claimed from the seller. Defective product liability covers damage that an unsafe product causes to people or to other property, and is directed mainly against the manufacturer or importer.
What damage is compensated for a defective product
- Personal injury, including death (art. 129.1).
- Property damage to other items objectively intended for private use or consumption and mainly used as such by the injured party (art. 129.1), with the 500 euro deductible (art. 141.a).
- Not included: damage to the defective product itself, which is claimed under civil and commercial law, for example through the guarantee (art. 142).
This regime does not exclude other compensation, including non-pecuniary damage, that may be due under contractual or non-contractual liability (art. 128). Clauses that seek to exclude or limit this liability are ineffective against the injured party (art. 130). The producer's overall liability for death and personal injury caused by identical products with the same defect is capped at 63,106,270.96 euros (art. 141.b), a figure designed for large serial incidents.
We assess without obligation whether you can get your money back.
Who do you claim against: manufacturer, importer or shop?
| Party | When liable | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer | Of the finished product, a component or a raw material | Arts. 135 and 138.1 |
| Importer into the European Union | Like the manufacturer | Art. 138.1 |
| Supplier or shop | If it does not identify the producer within three months, or if it sold the product knowing it was defective | Arts. 138.2 and 146 |
| Several liable parties | Jointly and severally liable to the injured party | Art. 132 |
Liability is not reduced because a third party also contributed to the damage (art. 133), but it may be reduced or removed if the injured party was also at fault, for example by using the product against the instructions (art. 145).
What you must prove before the courts in Palma and how the manufacturer defends itself
The burden of proof
The claimant must prove three things: the defect, the damage and the causal link between them (art. 139). In practice it is vital to keep the product or its remains without tampering with them, keep the receipt or invoice, photograph the scene, obtain medical or fire brigade reports and, where appropriate, commission an expert report.
The grounds for exemption
The producer is only released if it proves one of the grounds in article 140: that it did not put the product into circulation, that the defect probably did not exist at that time, that it did not manufacture it for economic purposes or in the course of its business, that the defect is due to mandatory rules, or that the state of scientific and technical knowledge did not allow the defect to be discovered. This last excuse is not accepted for medicines or food intended for human consumption (art. 140.3).
Time limits and steps to claim in Mallorca
- Act within three years of suffering the damage, if you know who is liable (art. 143.1). The limitation period is interrupted by an out-of-court claim (art. 1973 of the Civil Code), so it is advisable to send a burofax as soon as possible.
- Bear in mind the ten-year limit from when the specific product was put into circulation, unless court proceedings have been started before then (art. 144).
- Identify the liable party: manufacturer or importer according to the labelling; if none appears, require the shop to identify them.
- Report the incident to your insurer if the damage affects your home; the insurer can later claim against the manufacturer.
- Attempt a settlement before suing, as required by article 5 of Organic Act 1/2025.
If the injuries are also due to the careless conduct of a specific person, there may be criminal liability as well; we explain this in our guide on injury caused by negligence. And if your home insurance refuses to cover the damage, see how to claim against the insurer.
In 2024 the European Union adopted a new directive on liability for defective products which Spain must transpose into its law; in the meantime, the regime of the consolidated text explained here applies. At our office in Palma we assess your case within our claims practice and, if necessary, bring proceedings before the courts of Palma, Inca or Manacor.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I claim against the shop where I bought the product that injured me?
Under this regime, you generally claim against the manufacturer or importer. The shop is liable if it does not identify the producer within three months or if it sold the product knowing it was defective. For the product not working, you can claim against the shop under the guarantee.
What is the time limit to claim for a defective product in Mallorca?
Three years from when you suffered the damage, if you know who is liable. In addition, the rights are extinguished ten years after the product was put into circulation unless court proceedings have been started.
Will I be compensated for the appliance that exploded?
Not under this regime: damage to the product itself is claimed under civil and commercial law, for example through the guarantee. Personal injury and damage to other private property are compensated.
Why are 500 euros deducted from my compensation?
The law sets a 500 euro deductible that is subtracted from compensation for property damage. It does not apply to personal injury.
Do I have to show how the product was badly made?
You do not need to explain the manufacturing process, but you must prove that the product was defective, the damage and that the damage was caused by the defect. Keeping the product and a good expert report are decisive.