Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Employment law guide

Disciplinary dismissal in Mallorca: grounds, the dismissal letter and how to challenge it

Disciplinary dismissal is the most serious sanction an employer can impose: it ends the contract because of a serious and culpable breach by the employee and, if it is fair, gives no right to severance pay. Precisely for that reason the law requires a proven cause and a letter setting out the facts. We explain the grounds, what the letter must contain and how to challenge it.

Grounds for disciplinary dismissal (article 54)

Article 54.1 of the Workers' Statute allows dismissal based on a serious and culpable breach by the employee. Paragraph 2 lists the breaches that may justify it:

  1. Repeated and unjustified absences or lateness.
  2. Indiscipline or disobedience at work.
  3. Verbal or physical abuse of the employer, colleagues or family members living with them.
  4. Breach of contractual good faith and abuse of trust in performing the work.
  5. A continued and voluntary decrease in normal or agreed performance.
  6. Habitual drunkenness or drug addiction, if it has a negative impact on work.
  7. Harassment on grounds of racial or ethnic origin, religion or belief, disability, age or sexual orientation, and sexual or gender-based harassment.

It is not enough for the conduct to fit the list: it must be serious and culpable. The courts weigh the circumstances of the case and proportionality, and the collective agreement usually grades misconduct as minor, serious or very serious. Minor misconduct does not allow dismissal.

The disciplinary dismissal letter

What the letter must contain

The dismissal must be notified in writing, stating the facts behind it and the date on which it takes effect (art. 55.1 of the Workers' Statute). The facts must be described specifically enough (what, when, where) for you to defend yourself. A generic letter, such as «poor performance» or «loss of trust» without details, may lead to the dismissal being declared unfair. The collective agreement may add other formal requirements.

Additional safeguards

  • If you are a legal workers' representative or a union delegate, the employer must open adversarial proceedings in which you and the other members of the representation are heard.
  • If you are a union member and the employer knows it, it must first hear the union delegates of your union section.
  • If the letter is formally defective, the employer may carry out a new dismissal within 20 days of the first, paying the salary for the days in between and keeping you registered with Social Security (art. 55.2 of the Workers' Statute).

Time limits for misconduct

The employer cannot dismiss you for old facts. Under article 60.2 of the Workers' Statute, minor misconduct becomes time-barred after 10 days, serious misconduct after 20 and very serious misconduct after 60, counted from when the employer became aware of it, and in any event six months after it was committed.

Have you been dismissed?

You only have 20 working days to challenge it. Call us today.

Fair, unfair or null: what the court in Palma decides

ClassificationWhenConsequence
FairThe breach alleged in the letter is provenTermination without severance or back pay (art. 55.7 Workers' Statute)
UnfairThe breach is not proven or the letter does not meet the formal requirementsReinstatement or 33 days per year, up to 24 months' pay, at the employer's choice within 5 days (art. 56.1 Workers' Statute)
NullDiscrimination, violation of fundamental rights or protected situations (pregnancy, care leave, among others)Immediate reinstatement with the salary lost in the meantime (art. 55.5 and 55.6 Workers' Statute)

If the employer chooses to reinstate you after an unfair dismissal, it must pay you back pay (salarios de tramitación) from the dismissal until notification of the judgment (art. 56.2 of the Workers' Statute). If you are a workers' representative, the choice is yours (art. 56.4). For contracts signed before 12 February 2012, the period before that date is calculated at 45 days per year (eleventh transitional provision of the Workers' Statute).

Even if the disciplinary dismissal is fair, you are legally unemployed and can apply for benefit if you meet the requirements (art. 267.1.a of the General Social Security Act).

How to challenge a disciplinary dismissal in Mallorca step by step

  1. Sign the letter with the date of receipt and, if you disagree, «no conforme». Signing only proves that you have received it.
  2. File the conciliation request with the TAMIB within the 20 working days (art. 59.3 of the Workers' Statute and art. 103 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act). Filing it suspends the deadline; see our guide to the conciliation request.
  3. Court claim within the time remaining, before the employment section of the Court of First Instance (Tribunal de Instancia) in Palma, which has jurisdiction for the whole of Mallorca, including if you work in Inca or Manacor.
  4. Trial: the employer speaks first and must prove the facts in the letter, without being able to rely on new reasons (art. 105 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act).

If the dismissal hides retaliation for reporting workplace harassment or for asserting your rights, it may be declared null. We also recommend reviewing the differences from objective dismissal and our general guide to dismissals.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Am I entitled to severance pay in a disciplinary dismissal?

If it is declared fair, no. If it is declared unfair, the employer must reinstate you or pay you 33 days per year worked up to a maximum of 24 months' pay.

Can I claim unemployment benefit if I am dismissed on disciplinary grounds?

Yes. Dismissal, including disciplinary dismissal, is a legal situation of unemployment, provided you meet the contribution requirements.

What happens if the dismissal letter does not explain the facts properly?

If the facts are not specific enough for you to defend yourself, the dismissal may be declared unfair on formal grounds. At trial the employer cannot add reasons that are not in the letter.

Can I be dismissed for something that happened months ago?

It depends. Very serious misconduct becomes time-barred 60 days after the employer learned of it and, in any event, six months after it was committed.

How long do I have to claim?

20 working days from the dismissal, not counting Saturdays, Sundays or public holidays. The conciliation request suspends the deadline, but it is best to file it as soon as possible.

You may also be interested in