Grounds for objective dismissal (article 52)
Article 52 of the Workers' Statute lists the grounds that allow an objective dismissal:
- Incompetence of the employee, known or arising after they joined the company. Incompetence that already existed when the probationary period was passed cannot be relied on afterwards.
- Failure to adapt to reasonable technical changes in the job. The employer must first offer an adaptation course and wait at least two months from the change or from the end of the training.
- Economic, technical, organisational or production reasons, where the terminations affect fewer employees than required for a collective dismissal under article 51.1.
- Lack of budget allocation in open-ended contracts with non-profit organisations carrying out public plans and programmes without stable funding.
The former ground of absences from work, even justified ones, has been repealed: today an employee cannot be dismissed for absenteeism by this route.
Economic, technical, organisational or production reasons
What each reason means
Article 51.1 of the Workers' Statute defines them as follows:
- Economic: a negative economic situation, such as current or expected losses or a persistent fall in ordinary revenue or sales. It is persistent if for three consecutive quarters the revenue of each quarter is lower than in the same quarter of the previous year.
- Technical: changes in the means or instruments of production.
- Organisational: changes in the systems and methods of work or in the way production is organised.
- Production: changes in demand for the company's products or services.
Objective or collective dismissal
If within a 90-day period the terminations on these grounds reach 10 employees in companies with fewer than 100, 10% of the workforce in those with 100 to 300, or 30 in those with more than 300, the employer must follow the collective dismissal procedure with a consultation period. Below those thresholds an individual objective dismissal is possible. Workers' representatives have priority to remain in the company in these dismissals.
You only have 20 working days to challenge it. Call us today.
Formal requirements: letter, severance and notice
| Requirement | Content | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Written notice | Must state the reason in enough detail for you to defend yourself | Art. 53.1.a Workers' Statute |
| Severance pay | 20 days' salary per year of service, pro rata by months, up to a maximum of 12 months' pay, made available when the letter is delivered | Art. 53.1.b Workers' Statute |
| Notice | 15 days from delivery of the letter to termination; for art. 52.c grounds, a copy to the workers' representatives | Art. 53.1.c Workers' Statute |
| Time off to look for work | 6 hours a week during the notice period, with no loss of pay | Art. 53.2 Workers' Statute |
If the reason is economic and, precisely because of that situation, the employer cannot pay the severance when delivering the letter, it may withhold it provided it says so in the letter, and you can demand payment when the termination takes effect. Furthermore, failing to give notice or making an excusable error in calculating the severance do not in themselves make the dismissal unfair, but the employer must pay the salary for the notice period and the difference in severance (art. 53.4 of the Workers' Statute).
How to challenge an objective dismissal in Mallorca
An objective dismissal is challenged in the same way as a disciplinary one (art. 53.3 of the Workers' Statute): you have 20 working days from the date of dismissal (art. 59.3 of the Workers' Statute and art. 103 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act). Before filing a claim you must submit the conciliation request to the TAMIB, which suspends that deadline. Without agreement, the claim is filed with the employment section of the Court of First Instance (Tribunal de Instancia) in Palma, which hears employment cases from the whole of Mallorca, including those from Inca and Manacor.
Collecting the severance and signing the final settlement «no conforme» does not prevent you from challenging the dismissal. What matters is not to miss the deadline.
What the employment court in Palma can declare
- Fair: if the employer proves the reason and met the requirements. You keep the 20 days' severance and are legally unemployed (art. 53.5.a of the Workers' Statute and art. 267.1.a of the General Social Security Act).
- Unfair: if the reason is not proven or requirements are missing. The employer chooses within five days between reinstating you or paying 33 days per year up to a maximum of 24 months' pay (art. 56.1 of the Workers' Statute). If you are reinstated, you repay the severance received; if the employer pays, the amount already paid is deducted (art. 53.5.b).
- Null: if the dismissal is discriminatory or violates fundamental rights, or affects specially protected people, such as pregnant employees or those taking certain care leave, unless it is shown that the reason specifically requires their dismissal (art. 53.4 of the Workers' Statute). The consequence is reinstatement with the salary lost in the meantime.
Because the severance is lower than for an unfair dismissal, objective dismissal is sometimes used without a solid reason. Analysing the letter and the financial documentation is key. You can see the differences from disciplinary dismissal and the other cases in our general guide to dismissals.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
How much am I entitled to in an objective dismissal?
20 days' salary per year worked, pro rata by months for periods of less than a year, up to a maximum of 12 months' pay. If the dismissal is declared unfair, compensation rises to 33 days per year up to a maximum of 24 months' pay.
What happens if the employer does not give me 15 days' notice?
That alone does not make the dismissal unfair, but the employer must pay you the salary for the days of notice not given.
Can I claim unemployment benefit after an objective dismissal?
Yes. Termination for objective reasons is a legal situation of unemployment, even if the dismissal is declared fair.
Can I challenge the dismissal if I have already received the severance?
Yes. Collecting the severance does not mean accepting the dismissal. If it is declared unfair and the employer pays, what you have already received will be deducted.
Can I be dismissed for being on sick leave many times?
The ground of absences from work in the former article 52.d of the Workers' Statute has been repealed. A dismissal based on medical leave must be analysed carefully, because it may be unfair or even null.