Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Employment law guide

Warnings and disciplinary sanctions in Mallorca: how to challenge a sanction from your employer

An employer may sanction an employee who fails to meet their obligations, from a warning to suspension without pay. But it can only do so for offences laid down by law or the collective agreement, following the required form and limitation periods. We explain which sanctions are possible, what requirements they must meet and how to challenge them in Mallorca.

The employer's disciplinary power and its limits

Article 58.1 of the Workers' Statute (ET) allows management to sanction breaches of employment obligations, but always in accordance with the scale of offences and sanctions laid down by law or the applicable collective agreement. This means the employer cannot invent offences or sanctions: it has to fit the conduct into a defined offence and apply the sanction that corresponds to its seriousness.

In Mallorca, many employees are covered by sector agreements such as hospitality, retail or construction, which classify offences as minor, serious and very serious and set the possible sanctions for each. The first thing we check, therefore, is which agreement applies and what it says.

Sanctions that are prohibited

Article 58.3 ET prohibits sanctions that reduce holidays or other rest entitlements, as well as fines on wages, that is, deducting money from your pay as a punishment. A prohibited sanction, or one not provided for in the law or the agreement, is null and void (art. 115.1.d LRJS).

Warnings, suspension without pay and other common sanctions in Mallorca

Collective agreements usually provide, from least to most serious:

  • A verbal or written warning, for minor offences.
  • Suspension of work and pay for a number of days, the maximum length depending on the seriousness of the offence under the agreement.
  • Dismissal, reserved for very serious offences amounting to a serious and culpable breach.

Dismissal is the most serious sanction and has its own rules; see our guide on disciplinary dismissal.

Have you been dismissed?

You only have 20 working days to challenge it. Call us today.

Formal requirements and limitation periods for offences

The sanction letter

To sanction serious or very serious offences, the employer must give notice in writing, stating the date and the facts giving rise to the sanction (art. 58.2 ET). The facts must be described specifically enough for you to defend yourself. The collective agreement may require additional steps, such as a prior file, and failure to follow them may make the sanction void.

Safeguards for workers' representatives

If you are a member of the works council or a staff delegate, a sanction for a serious or very serious offence requires an adversarial procedure in which you and the other representatives are heard (art. 68.a ET). Without it, the sanction is void (art. 115.2 LRJS).

Limitation periods for offences

Type of offenceTime-barred after the employer learns of itMaximum period from commission
Minor10 days6 months
Serious20 days6 months
Very serious60 days6 months

If the employer sanctions you for facts it has known about for longer than the period allowed, the offence is time-barred and the sanction cannot stand (art. 60.2 ET).

How to challenge a sanction before the courts in Palma

  1. Sign for receipt adding «no conforme» (not in agreement). Your signature only proves you received the notice, not that you accept the facts.
  2. File the conciliation request within 20 working days. It is a mandatory prior step (art. 63 LRJS) and suspends the time limit; see our guide on the conciliation request.
  3. Court claim within the remaining time before the employment section of the Court of First Instance in Palma, also if you work in Inca, Manacor or any other town on the island. The time limit is the same as for dismissal and cannot be extended (arts. 103 and 114.1 LRJS).
  4. Trial: the employer must prove the facts and their seriousness, and cannot rely on grounds other than those stated when it imposed the sanction (art. 114.3 LRJS).

What the judge can decide about your sanction

Under article 115.1 LRJS, the judgment may:

  • Confirm the sanction, if the facts, their seriousness and compliance with the formal requirements are proven.
  • Revoke it entirely, if the facts are not proven or do not amount to an offence, ordering payment of the wages you lost.
  • Revoke it in part, if the offence exists but was classified as more serious than it was; the employer may then impose an appropriate sanction within ten days of the judgment becoming final.
  • Declare it void, for serious formal defects, discrimination or breach of fundamental rights, or because the sanction is prohibited or not defined.

No appeal (recurso de suplicación) lies against the judgment if the sanction concerns a minor or serious offence, or a very serious offence not upheld by the judge (art. 191.2.a LRJS). If sanctions follow one another to put pressure on you or isolate you, they may be a sign of workplace harassment. We can help you through our employment law department in Palma.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to challenge a sanction in Mallorca?

20 working days from notification, not counting Saturdays, Sundays or public holidays. The conciliation request suspends the time limit.

Can money be deducted from my wages as a sanction?

No. Fines on wages are prohibited. Suspension of work and pay, during which you neither work nor are paid for the days of the sanction, is a different matter if the agreement provides for it.

Can a verbal warning be challenged?

The assessment of any offence can be reviewed by the court, although in practice it is mainly worth challenging written sanctions, because they may serve as a precedent for more serious ones.

Can I be sanctioned for something I did months ago?

It depends on the seriousness. Minor offences become time-barred after 10 days, serious ones after 20 and very serious ones after 60 from when the employer learns of them, and all of them six months after being committed.

What happens if I win the case?

If the sanction is revoked, the employer must pay you the wages you lost through the suspension. If it is declared void, it has no effect, as if it had never been imposed.

You may also be interested in