Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

International criminal law guide

The European Investigation Order in criminal matters

Many criminal proceedings handled in Mallorca involve evidence located in other European countries: bank accounts, witnesses, company records or data from devices. The European Investigation Order allows judicial authorities of the European Union to obtain that evidence quickly from one another. We explain how it works and what the defence can do.

What it is

The European Investigation Order replaced the old letters rogatory between the European Union States that apply Directive 2014/41/EU. In Spain it is regulated in Title X of Law 23/2014 on the mutual recognition of criminal decisions. It allows another State to be asked for measures such as:

  • Taking statements from witnesses, victims, experts or suspects, including by videoconference.
  • Obtaining banking and financial information.
  • Gathering data from telecommunications operators and internet service providers.
  • Searches, interceptions and controlled deliveries.
  • Sending evidence or investigative material already held by its authorities.

Who can issue it in Spain

The issuing authorities are the judges and courts hearing the proceedings in which the measure must be adopted, and public prosecutors in the proceedings they direct, provided that the measure does not restrict fundamental rights (art. 187). The parties, including the defence, can ask the judge to issue it in order to obtain evidence in their favour.

Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

How it is executed

  1. The issuing authority completes a standard form and sends it to the competent authority of the other State.
  2. That authority recognises it and executes it as if it were a measure ordered by its own authorities.
  3. Execution must take place without delay and, at the latest, within 90 days of the decision on recognition, unless there are grounds for postponement.
  4. The evidence obtained is sent to the issuing State.

Grounds for refusal

The State receiving the order may refuse it in a closed list of cases: immunities, harm to essential national security interests, breach of the principle that no one may be tried twice for the same facts (non bis in idem), facts that are not an offence in that State outside a list of serious offences, or incompatibility with fundamental rights. Some measures may only be taken if they would be allowed in a similar domestic case.

The role of the defence

  • Requesting evidence abroad: documents, witnesses or data proving the suspect's innocence.
  • Reviewing the lawfulness of the evidence obtained: if fundamental rights were breached when it was gathered, its exclusion can be requested.
  • Coordinating with lawyers in the other country when the execution has to be challenged there.

These orders are common in investigations into financial crime and cybercrime, during the preliminary investigation (diligencias previas). For the arrest and surrender of persons there is a different instrument, the European Arrest Warrant. If you are a foreign national involved in such proceedings, you are entitled to an interpreter and to the translation of essential documents.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the European Investigation Order and the European Arrest Warrant?

The Investigation Order is used to obtain evidence in another country. The Arrest Warrant is used to have a person arrested and surrendered.

Can the defence request a European Investigation Order?

Yes. It can ask the judge hearing the case to issue it in order to obtain evidence in its favour in another European Union State.

How long does it take?

The receiving State must execute it without delay and, at the latest, within 90 days of recognising it, unless there are justified postponements.

Can evidence obtained abroad be challenged?

Yes, if it was obtained in breach of fundamental rights or without respecting the applicable safeguards.

Does it apply to all EU countries?

It applies between the States that take part in Directive 2014/41/EU. With the others, different cooperation instruments are still used.

You may also be interested in

Criminal law

Extradition and the European Arrest Warrant

Extradition lawyers in Mallorca: European Arrest Warrant and surrender, passive extradition before the National High Court, deadlines, safeguards and defence.

Read →