What prevaricación is
Article 404 of the Criminal Code punishes any authority or public official who, knowing it to be unjust, issues an arbitrary decision in an administrative matter. The penalty is special disqualification from public employment or office and from the right to stand for election for a period of 9 to 15 years.
The case law of the Spanish Supreme Court requires:
- A decision issued by an authority or official in an administrative matter, which rules on the substance of the case.
- That it is objectively contrary to the law in an obvious way: because essential procedural steps were omitted, because there was a complete lack of competence, or because its content has no reasonable legal justification whatsoever.
- That it is arbitrary: that it reflects only the will of its author and not the law.
- That it is issued knowing that it is unjust.
Malfeasance or administrative illegality
Most unlawful administrative decisions are not crimes. They are annulled through administrative appeals or before the administrative courts (juzgados de lo contencioso-administrativo), as we explain in administrative law. Criminal law only steps in when the illegality is so evident and deliberate that it amounts to arbitrariness. Telling the two apart is the key both to reporting a case and to defending oneself against an accusation.
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
Typical cases
- Planning permissions granted in breach of the zoning plan, or refused for personal reasons, often together with planning offences.
- Public contracts and awards made without any tender procedure, or split into smaller contracts to avoid one.
- Appointments and hiring of staff bypassing the selection processes.
- Grants and subsidies awarded without a public call or without meeting the requirements.
Other forms of prevaricación
The Criminal Code also punishes judicial prevaricación by judges and magistrates, with its own penalties, and that of the official who fails to perform specific duties, such as not prosecuting offences of which they are aware. When money changes hands, bribery is usually involved as well; when there is pressure from third parties, influence peddling.
The defence
- Showing that the decision was based on a tenable legal interpretation, even if a debatable one.
- Demonstrating that the technical and legal reports in the file were followed, which in many cases rules out intent.
- Analysing whether the act was a decision in the proper sense or merely a procedural step.
These cases are often technically complex and require a careful reading of the whole administrative file, from the first report to the final decision. If you are a foreign national affected by a decision of a Mallorcan town hall or of the regional government, we can advise you in English, German, Spanish and Mallorquin, and assess whether the right route is criminal, administrative, or both.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Is an unlawful decision always prevaricación?
No. It is only a crime if the illegality is obvious and gross and the official issues the decision knowing it to be unjust. Any other illegality is challenged through administrative appeals and judicial review before the administrative courts.
What is the penalty for prevaricación?
Special disqualification from public employment or office and from the right to stand for election for 9 to 15 years. It carries no prison sentence.
Can a town councillor commit prevaricación?
Yes. Councillors and mayors are authorities for the purposes of criminal law and can commit prevaricación when they vote for or issue arbitrary administrative decisions.
Does following a technical report rule out the offence?
It is usually an important argument against the existence of intent, unless the report is manifestly wrong or was obtained to cover up the arbitrariness.
Who can report prevaricación?
Anyone can report it. Those harmed by the decision may also join the proceedings as a private prosecutor (acusación particular).