Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Criminal law guide

Concurrence of offences and of laws: sentencing when there are several offences

When a person commits several offences, or a single act fits several articles of the Criminal Code, it has to be decided how it is punished: by adding up the penalties, applying an aggravated one or choosing a single provision. These are technical rules, but many years of a sentence may depend on them.

Real concurrence

There is real concurrence (concurso real) when a person commits several independent acts, each constituting an offence. Article 73 requires all the penalties to be imposed, to be served simultaneously if possible or, if not, one after another. To avoid disproportionate sentences, article 76 limits the time actually served to three times the most serious penalty imposed, with a maximum of 20 years, which is exceptionally raised to 25, 30 or 40 years for very serious offences.

Ideal and instrumental concurrence

TypeExampleRule (art. 77)
Ideal: a single act, several offencesA shot that kills one person and injures anotherPenalty for the most serious offence in its upper half, without exceeding the sum of the separate penalties
Instrumental: one offence is a necessary means for anotherForging a document to commit fraudA penalty higher than the one that would apply for the most serious offence, without exceeding the sum of the specific penalties

If the penalty calculated in this way turns out to be higher than punishing the offences separately, they are punished separately.

Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

Continuing offence

When someone carries out several acts, in execution of a preconceived plan or taking advantage of the same opportunity, which breach the same provision or similar provisions, they are punished as a single continuing offence (delito continuado) with the penalty for the most serious offence in its upper half, which may reach the lower half of the penalty one degree higher (art. 74). In property offences the total loss is taken into account, and if the act is notoriously serious and harms a large number of people, the penalty may be raised by one or two degrees. It is common in repeated frauds or misappropriations. In general, it does not apply to offences against eminently personal interests.

Concurrence of laws

Sometimes a single act appears to fit several articles, but in reality one of them already captures its full wrongfulness. Article 8 of the Criminal Code resolves these cases with four criteria, in this order:

  1. Speciality: the special provision takes precedence over the general one.
  2. Subsidiarity: the subsidiary provision only applies in the absence of the main one.
  3. Absorption: the broader or more complex provision absorbs those that punish offences included within it.
  4. Alternativity: failing the above, the more serious provision excludes the others.

For example, the violence inherent in a robbery with violence is absorbed into the robbery, but any injuries caused are punished separately.

Why it matters for the defence

Classifying the facts as ideal concurrence or a continuing offence, instead of real concurrence, can reduce the sentence by many years. The prosecution tends to classify each act separately; the defence reviews at the trial whether a single, unified classification is appropriate. If you are facing several charges in Mallorca, we can explain in English, German, Spanish and Mallorquin how these rules could affect your case.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Are all the penalties added together if I committed several offences?

In real concurrence they are all imposed, but the time actually served is limited to three times the most serious one and, in general, to 20 years.

What is a continuing offence?

Several acts of the same kind carried out under a preconceived plan or taking advantage of the same opportunity, which are punished as a single offence with an aggravated penalty.

What is instrumental concurrence?

When one offence is the necessary means of committing another, such as forging a document to commit fraud. A penalty higher than that for the most serious offence is imposed, without exceeding the sum of the two.

What is concurrence of laws?

When an act apparently fits several articles but only one should be applied, according to the criteria of speciality, subsidiarity, absorption or alternativity.

What is the maximum prison term that can be served?

As a general rule, 20 years, which rises to 25, 30 or 40 years in exceptional cases of very serious offences.

You may also be interested in