Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Criminal law guide

The retroactive effect of the more favourable criminal law

Criminal laws cannot be applied to earlier events to a person's detriment, but they can be applied to their benefit. If a reform reduces a penalty or abolishes an offence, it also applies to whoever committed the act beforehand, even if they have already been convicted. We explain how it works and how to apply for a review.

The principle of non-retroactivity

Article 2.1 of the Criminal Code and Article 25 of the Constitution prevent an act from being punished with a penalty that was not provided for when it was committed, or with a heavier penalty than the one in force at that time. It is a basic guarantee of legal certainty: no one can be punished for something that was lawful when they did it.

The exception: the more favourable law

Article 2.2 provides that criminal laws favouring the offender have retroactive effect, even if a final judgment had been handed down when they came into force and the convicted person was serving the sentence. This happens when a reform:

  • Abolishes an offence, as happened with sedition in 2022, which we explain in rebellion and sedition.
  • Reduces the penalty for an offence or changes the requirements of an aggravating circumstance.
  • Turns an offence into an administrative infringement or a minor offence.
  • Improves the rules on serving sentences or on expunging criminal records.
Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

How the more favourable law is determined

The two laws must be compared as a whole, applied to the specific case, rather than taking the most beneficial parts of each. In case of doubt, the court must hear the offender before deciding. Sometimes a reform lowers the minimum penalty but raises the maximum, or removes one penalty and adds another: the analysis requires calculating the specific penalty that would result under each law.

Review of final judgments

When a more favourable law comes into force, the courts that handed down convictions still being enforced must review them. The convicted person can apply for a review through their lawyer. If the new penalty is lower than the time already served, they must be released; if the act ceases to be an offence, the conviction is set aside, with consequences also for the criminal record and its expungement.

Do you have a trial coming up?

We review your case without obligation and explain your real options.

Temporary laws

Acts committed while a temporary law, passed for a specific period, was in force are judged under that law, unless the law itself provides otherwise. This is an exception to favourable retroactivity.

Security measures

Laws establishing security measures, such as supervised release, do not have retroactive effect to the offender's detriment either (art. 2.1).

Why a review is worthwhile

The Spanish Criminal Code is amended frequently. Each reform may open the door to reducing sentences, obtaining a suspended sentence or bringing forward the expungement of criminal records. We review sentences being served whenever a relevant reform comes into force. This also applies to foreign nationals convicted in Spain, including those serving their sentence or living abroad.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Does a reform benefit me if I have already been convicted?

Yes, if the new law is more favourable in your specific case, even if the judgment is already final and you are serving the sentence.

Who decides which law is more favourable?

The court, by comparing the two laws as applied to your case and hearing you if there is any doubt.

Can a reform make my situation worse?

No. Unfavourable criminal laws do not apply to acts committed before they came into force.

What happened to those convicted of sedition?

When the offence was abolished, their convictions had to be reviewed, applying where appropriate the offences that remain in force.

Do I have to apply for the review or is it done automatically?

The courts must review sentences, but it is advisable to request it expressly through your lawyer to make sure it is applied.

You may also be interested in