What a substantial change is
Not every change is substantial. A change is substantial when it significantly alters essential aspects of the contract. Article 41.1 mentions, among others, changes affecting:
- Working hours.
- The schedule and distribution of working time.
- The shift work system.
- The pay system and the amount of salary.
- The work and performance system.
- Duties, when they go beyond the limits of functional mobility.
If the change is minor, it falls within the employer's ordinary management powers and does not require this procedure.
Requirements
- A proven reason: economic, technical, organisational or production reasons related to competitiveness, productivity or organisation.
- Notification in writing to the employee and their representatives at least 15 days in advance, if the change is individual.
- A consultation period with the workers' representatives, if the change is collective because it affects a minimum number of employees.
You only have 20 working days to challenge it. Call us today.
The employee's options
| Option | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Accept | The change applies. |
| Terminate the contract (if it is detrimental and affects working hours, schedule, shifts, pay or duties) | Compensation of 20 days per year up to a maximum of 9 months' pay (art. 41.3). |
| Challenge it before the Employment Court | Deadline of 20 working days from notification (art. 59.4). If the court declares it unjustified, the employee is restored to their previous conditions. |
| Request termination for serious breach (if it is made without following the procedure and harms their dignity) | Compensation for unfair dismissal (art. 50.1.a). |
Unlike in dismissal cases, prior conciliation is not mandatory when challenging substantial changes, as we explain in conciliation request.
The measure applies even if challenged
The change is enforceable from its effective date even if the employee challenges it. While the case is being decided, the employee must comply with it, unless it affects their dignity or is clearly unlawful. That is why it is advisable to act quickly and with advice.
Common cases in Mallorca
- Changes of shift or schedule at the start or end of the tourist season.
- Reductions in bonuses or commissions.
- Moving duties to a lower-category position.
If it is the employee who asks for a change in working hours for family reasons, different rules apply, which we explain in reduction and adaptation of working hours. If the employer is in serious breach, see termination for breach by the employer. We work in English, German, Spanish and Mallorquin, so you can review the employer's letter with us in your own language.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can my employer change my schedule without my consent?
It can if it is a substantial change with a proven reason and at least 15 days' notice. You can challenge it or terminate your contract with compensation.
How long do I have to challenge a substantial change?
20 working days from notification of the decision.
How much am I entitled to if I leave because of a substantial change?
20 days' salary per year worked, up to a maximum of 9 months' pay, if the change is detrimental to you and affects the matters specified by law.
Do I have to follow the new schedule while I challenge it?
Yes, as a general rule, because the change is enforceable. If it harms your dignity, the situation is different.
Is a pay cut a substantial change?
Yes, the amount of salary is one of the matters that can be subject to a substantial change, provided there is a reason and the limits of the collective agreement are respected.