Are they valid as evidence?
Yes. Messages on WhatsApp, Telegram, social media or email are accepted as evidence in criminal, civil and employment proceedings alike. The problem is not their admissibility but their authenticity: digital conversations can be manipulated relatively easily, for example by creating accounts under false names or editing screenshots.
The Supreme Court's case law
In 2015 the Supreme Court established that, when the authenticity of a conversation submitted as screenshots is challenged, the burden of proving its authenticity shifts to the party seeking to rely on it as evidence. In such cases an expert report is essential to identify the true origin of the communication, the identity of the participants and the integrity of its content. If no one challenges it, the screenshot can be assessed together with the rest of the evidence.
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
How to submit messages with proper safeguards
- Keep the phone and do not delete the conversation, even if you change device.
- Take complete screenshots showing the sender's number or profile, the date and time, and the context of the conversation, not just isolated sentences.
- Export the conversation using the app's own function.
- Notarial certificate (acta notarial): a notary can certify the content visible on the phone on a given date.
- Forensic IT expert report: this is the strongest evidence, because it analyses the device and verifies that the messages have not been altered.
If the messages are in English, German or another language, a sworn translation into Spanish will usually be needed for the court.
Unlawfully obtained messages
You can submit conversations in which you took part. By contrast, accessing another person's phone without authorisation to obtain their messages with third parties may constitute an offence of discovery and disclosure of secrets, and the evidence may be declared void for breaching the right to privacy and to the secrecy of communications, as we explain in annulment of proceedings.
How to defend yourself against messages
- Expressly challenge their authenticity and demand the device and an expert report.
- Point out the lack of context: messages that have been cropped or taken out of the full conversation.
- Dispute authorship: the fact that a number or profile is in your name does not prove that you wrote the messages.
- Submit the complete conversation from your own device.
Messages are common evidence in cases of threats and harassment. In any event, they are assessed together with the rest of the evidence and subject to the presumption of innocence.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Is a WhatsApp screenshot valid in court?
It may be, if the other party does not challenge it. If its authenticity is challenged, a forensic IT expert report will normally be required.
Can I record or use a conversation I took part in?
Yes. You can submit conversations in which you are a participant. What breaches privacy is accessing other people's communications.
Are WhatsApp voice messages valid?
Yes, just like written messages. If their authenticity or the identity of the speaker is disputed, a voice expert report may be needed.
What should I do if I have deleted the messages?
Sometimes they can be recovered from backups or from the other participant's device. An IT expert can assess this.
Is a notarial certificate or an expert better?
A notarial certificate attests to what can be seen on the screen at a given moment. An expert can also verify the origin and integrity of the messages, which makes it the strongest evidence if there is a challenge.