What the presumption of innocence is
Article 24.2 of the Constitution grants everyone the right to the presumption of innocence. In criminal proceedings this means that:
- The accused does not have to prove their innocence: it is the prosecution that must prove the facts and the accused's involvement.
- A conviction requires sufficient incriminating evidence.
- That evidence must have been lawfully obtained and examined publicly, orally, directly before the court and with the opportunity to challenge it.
- The court must explain in the judgment why that evidence leads it to convict.
The presumption of innocence also applies outside the trial: no one may be treated as guilty until there is a final conviction.
Incriminating evidence
Incriminating evidence (prueba de cargo) is evidence whose content allows the court to establish the facts alleged by the prosecution and the accused's involvement. It can be direct (a witness who saw the events, a recording) or indirect, through circumstantial indications, as we explain in circumstantial evidence. To be valid it must:
- Have been obtained without breaching fundamental rights. Unlawful evidence has no effect, as we explain in annulment of proceedings.
- As a general rule, be examined at the trial; investigative steps taken during the pre-trial phase are only valid in a limited number of cases, such as pre-recorded evidence (prueba preconstituida).
- Be sufficient to support the conviction beyond all reasonable doubt.
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
In dubio pro reo
This is a rule for weighing evidence: if, after analysing all the evidence, the court does not reach certainty about guilt and retains a reasonable doubt, it must acquit. It does not mean that any imaginable doubt requires an acquittal, but a reasonable doubt grounded in the evidence itself.
The victim's statement
In many offences (sexual assaults, gender-based violence, threats) the main evidence is the victim's statement. The Supreme Court accepts that it can be enough to convict if it passes a rigorous examination of:
- Subjective credibility: absence of improper motives, such as resentment or financial interest.
- Plausibility: internal consistency and corroboration by objective peripheral data (medical reports, messages, hearsay witnesses).
- Persistence in the accusation: no significant contradictions throughout the proceedings.
These criteria are not formal requirements but parameters for weighing the evidence. The defence has the right to challenge that statement and to highlight its weaknesses.
Other common evidence
Statements by police officers, expert reports, recordings and WhatsApp messages are common types of evidence. All of them must be open to challenge at trial, and their authenticity can be disputed. If you do not speak Spanish, you are entitled to an interpreter throughout the proceedings so that you can follow and challenge the evidence against you.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to prove that I am innocent?
No. It is the prosecution that must prove the facts and your involvement. You have the right to remain silent and not to provide evidence against yourself.
What is reasonable doubt?
A doubt grounded in the evidence itself, which prevents the court from reaching certainty about guilt. If it exists, the court must acquit.
Can someone be convicted on the victim's statement alone?
Yes, if it is credible, plausible and persistent and is corroborated by peripheral data, according to the case law of the Supreme Court.
Does what I said at the police station count as evidence?
On its own, a statement made to the police is not incriminating evidence. What counts is the evidence examined at trial, save for legal exceptions.
What happens if the evidence was obtained illegally?
Evidence obtained in breach of fundamental rights has no effect and cannot support a conviction.