Grounds for nullity
Article 238 of the Organic Law on the Judiciary establishes that procedural acts are null and void:
- When they are carried out by or before a court without jurisdiction or without subject-matter or functional competence.
- When they are carried out under violence or intimidation.
- When essential rules of procedure are disregarded, provided that this may have caused a lack of defence.
- When they are carried out without a lawyer in cases where one is mandatory.
- When hearings are held without the court clerk (letrado de la Administración de Justicia).
- In the other cases established by the procedural laws.
The ground most often relied on is the third: lack of defence (indefensión). A formal irregularity is not enough; it must have deprived the party of a real opportunity to defend themselves, for example because they were not properly summoned.
How to request it
Through an appeal
The ordinary route is to raise nullity in the appeals against the decision affected (art. 240.1 of the Organic Law on the Judiciary). In criminal proceedings, it can also be raised at the start of the trial, when preliminary issues are dealt with.
By the court of its own motion or at the request of a party before the final decision
The judge may declare nullity, after hearing the parties, before the decision ending the proceedings is delivered, provided that the defect cannot be remedied (art. 240.2).
Special motion
When the decision is already final and no appeal lies, anyone who was or should have been a party can request annulment for the infringement of a fundamental right that they could not raise earlier. The time limit is 20 days from notification or from when the defect became known, and never more than 5 years from notification of the decision (art. 241). In many cases it is also a prerequisite for bringing an amparo appeal before the Constitutional Court.
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
Unlawful evidence in criminal proceedings
In criminal proceedings, nullity is particularly important in relation to evidence. Evidence obtained, directly or indirectly, in breach of fundamental rights has no effect (art. 11.1 of the Organic Law on the Judiciary). Examples include:
- Searches of homes without judicial authorisation or valid consent.
- Interception of telephones or devices without sufficient authorisation or with inadequate reasoning.
- Statements obtained without informing the arrested person of their rights or without a lawyer.
- Messages or data obtained in breach of privacy, as we explain under WhatsApp as evidence.
If the unlawful evidence was the only incriminating evidence, the result is acquittal for lack of evidence and respect for the presumption of innocence. That is why every investigative step should be reviewed from the preliminary investigation onwards.
Common cases
- Convictions handed down without the accused being properly summoned, as in some trials in absentia.
- Attachments and evictions in civil proceedings notified at the wrong address.
- Decisions issued without one of the parties being given notice.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
What is lack of defence?
The real deprivation of the opportunity to defend yourself in proceedings, for example because you were not summoned or could not submit evidence. It is the central requirement for annulment on procedural grounds.
How long do I have to request annulment of a final judgment?
In the special motion, 20 days from notification or from when the defect became known, and never more than 5 years from notification.
Can evidence be annulled in a criminal trial?
Yes. Evidence obtained in breach of fundamental rights has no effect, nor does evidence deriving directly from it.
I was notified at an old address: can I have the proceedings annulled?
If notification was not made properly and you were unaware of the proceedings, you can request annulment for lack of defence.
Does annulment mean the whole trial is repeated?
Normally the proceedings are taken back to the point at which the defect occurred, and the procedure is repeated from there.