What circumstantial evidence is
Circumstantial or indirect evidence consists of proving facts other than the offence itself (the indications) in order to reach, through logical reasoning, the conclusion that the accused committed the offence. For example: finding the stolen items in the accused's home, their fingerprints at the scene and their presence nearby at the time of the events.
Requirements under case law
For circumstantial evidence to support a conviction without breaching the presumption of innocence, case law requires:
As regards the indications
- That they are fully proven by direct evidence; one indication cannot be built on another indication.
- That they are several or, exceptionally, a single one of particular probative force.
- That they are concurrent with the fact to be proven.
- That they are interrelated and reinforce one another.
As regards the inference
- That the reasoning is rational, in line with logic and common experience.
- That it is not excessively open or weak: if the indications allow several reasonable alternative conclusions, it is not enough.
- That it is set out in the judgment, so that it can be reviewed on appeal.
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
Offences where it is common
- Money laundering: unexplained increases in wealth, transactions without economic logic, links to criminal activities.
- Drug trafficking: quantity and purity, cash in small amounts, scales, surveillance.
- Financial and corporate offences.
- Homicides with no direct witnesses.
- Burglaries with biological or fingerprint evidence.
A practical example
Imagine a charge of burglary of a home with no witnesses. The prosecution puts forward three indications: the accused's fingerprints on the forced window, their phone located in the area that night and the sale of a stolen piece of jewellery a few days later. Separately, each one admits other explanations; together, they point in the same direction. The defence might, for example, prove that the accused had worked in that house a few days earlier (which explains the fingerprints) or that the jewellery was sold to them by an identifiable third party. If those explanations are reasonable, the conclusion is no longer the only one possible.
How to defend yourself against circumstantial evidence
- Attack the indications: show that one of them is not fully proven or was obtained unlawfully.
- Offer reasonable alternative explanations: the lawful origin of the money, a justified presence at the scene, earlier contact with the object.
- Point to counter-indications: proven facts that point in the opposite direction.
- Challenge the inference: show that the conclusion is neither the only possible one nor the most likely.
The alternative explanation does not have to be fully proven: it is enough for it to be reasonable to create a doubt that prevents a conviction. All of this is argued at the trial.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can someone be convicted without direct evidence?
Yes, through circumstantial evidence, provided that the indications are fully proven, several and linked, and the conclusion is rational and the only reasonable one.
Is a single indication enough for a conviction?
Exceptionally, if it has particular probative force. Normally several converging indications are required.
What is a counter-indication?
A proven fact that points in the opposite direction to the prosecution's case and weakens the conclusion based on the indications.
Do I have to prove my alternative explanation?
Not fully. It is enough for it to be reasonable and not contradicted by the evidence for there to be a doubt that prevents a conviction.
What happens if the judgment does not explain the reasoning?
A failure to give reasons for the inference drawn from the indications can lead to the judgment being set aside on appeal.