Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Criminal law guide

Civil liability arising from a criminal offence: how victims are compensated in Mallorca

Every offence that causes harm creates an obligation to make it good. In Spain, the victim does not need a separate civil lawsuit: compensation is normally claimed and decided within the criminal proceedings themselves, and the public prosecutor claims it even if the victim does not join the proceedings. We explain what it covers, who is liable, how payment is secured and when it is advisable to reserve the civil claim.

What civil liability arising from a crime covers

Article 109 of the Criminal Code provides that committing an act defined by law as an offence creates an obligation to make good the loss and damage caused. Article 110 sets out three elements:

  • Restitution: returning the same item, with payment for any deterioration, even if it is held by a third party who acquired it in good faith, unless it was acquired in a way that makes it irrecoverable (art. 111).
  • Repair of the damage: obligations to give, do or refrain from doing, set by the judge according to the nature of the damage and the offender's circumstances (art. 112).
  • Compensation for material and moral damage, both that caused to the victim and that suffered by relatives or third parties (art. 113).

The judge must explain in the judgment the grounds on which the amount is based, and may set it in the judgment itself or at the enforcement stage (art. 115). In road traffic accidents the damage assessment system of the Act on civil liability and insurance in the use of motor vehicles also applies; we explain it in our guide to road traffic accidents.

Who has to pay the compensation

Liable partyWhen liableLegal basis
The convicted personWhenever the offence causes damage; if there are several, the judge sets each one's shareArt. 116 Criminal Code
The insurerDirectly liable up to the statutory or agreed limit, if the risk was insuredArt. 117 Criminal Code
Employers and owners of premises or vehiclesSecondarily, for offences committed by their employees, agents or authorised persons in the cases provided by lawArt. 120 Criminal Code
Public authoritiesSecondarily, for offences by officials acting in the course of their dutiesArt. 121 Criminal Code
Recipient of gainsAnyone who benefited from the proceeds of the offence without taking part in it, up to the amount of the benefitArt. 122 Criminal Code

Principals and accomplices are jointly and severally liable within each category, with a right of recourse against the others (art. 116.2). Exemption from criminal liability does not always remove civil liability: for example, in cases of mental disorder or intoxication the offender remains liable and, where there was fault, so do those providing support (art. 118). In a tourism economy such as Mallorca's, this regime may extend, for example, to hotels, nightlife venues or vehicle hire companies, provided the requirements of article 120 are met.

Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

How to claim compensation in criminal proceedings in Mallorca

Every offence gives rise to a criminal action and may also give rise to a civil action for restitution, repair and compensation (art. 100 of the Criminal Procedure Act). If you bring only the criminal action, the civil action is deemed to be brought as well (art. 112). And even if you do not join the proceedings, the public prosecutor will claim compensation on your behalf unless you expressly waive it (art. 108).

Joining the proceedings, however, has advantages: you can quantify the damage yourself, submit invoices, medical and expert reports, and appeal. You can do so as a private prosecutor or only as a civil claimant, always before the stage at which the charges are formally set out (art. 110). If you have not yet reported the offence, see who can do so in our guide who can report a crime?

Securing payment: bonds and seizures

As soon as there is evidence against a person, the judge may require a bond to secure the financial liabilities and, if it is not provided, seize sufficient assets (art. 589 of the Criminal Procedure Act). In the abbreviated procedure the precautionary measures of the Civil Procedure Act apply, and where there is compulsory insurance the insurer is required to provide security up to its limit (art. 764). Requesting these measures early prevents the liable person from disposing of their assets.

Reserving or waiving the civil claim

The injured party may choose to claim compensation before the civil courts (art. 109.2 of the Criminal Code). To do so, the civil claim must be expressly reserved; while the criminal proceedings are pending, it cannot be brought separately until there is a final judgment (art. 111 of the Criminal Procedure Act). Reserving it may be advisable for complex damage, when injuries have not yet stabilised or when there are several liable parties who should be sued together.

A waiver must be clear and unequivocal (art. 110). Even so, it can be revoked by court decision before the charges are set out if the consequences of the offence are more serious than expected or if the waiver was influenced by the relationship with the offender (art. 112).

If the accused is acquitted or the case is closed

Extinction of the criminal action does not extinguish the civil one, unless a final judgment declares that the act from which it could arise did not occur (art. 116 of the Criminal Procedure Act). In all other cases you can claim before the civil courts.

How compensation is collected in Mallorca and incentives to pay

Payments by the convicted person are applied first to repairing the damage and compensation, before costs and the fine (art. 126 of the Criminal Code), and the judge may allow payment in instalments after hearing the injured party (art. 125). Paying is also in the offender's interest: repairing the damage before trial is a mitigating circumstance (art. 21.5ª) and satisfying civil liability, or undertaking to do so, is a requirement for a suspended sentence (art. 80.2.3ª). At Castell Abogados we represent victims in Spanish, English and German. Call us on 684 450 450.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to join the proceedings to receive compensation?

It is not essential: the public prosecutor claims it on your behalf unless you waive it. Joining the proceedings, however, allows you to quantify the damage better, submit evidence and appeal.

Is moral damage compensated?

Yes. Compensation covers material and moral damage, both to the victim and to relatives or third parties, under article 113 of the Criminal Code.

What happens if the convicted person has no money?

You can claim against parties that are directly or secondarily liable, such as their insurer or their employer in the cases provided by law. That is why it is important to request bonds and seizures from the outset.

Does a pardon for the offender prevent me from being paid?

No. A pardon never covers civil compensation, which remains enforceable.

Can I claim in the civil courts instead of the criminal ones?

Yes, by expressly reserving the civil claim. You will have to wait until the criminal proceedings end with a final decision before filing the civil lawsuit.

You may also be interested in