Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Criminal law guide

Final and provisional dismissal: closing a criminal case

Dismissal (sobreseimiento) is the closing of criminal proceedings without going to trial. For the person under investigation it is the best possible outcome; for the victim it may be a disappointment that can still be appealed. There are two types, with very different effects: final dismissal (sobreseimiento libre) and provisional dismissal (sobreseimiento provisional).

Final dismissal

Article 637 of the Criminal Procedure Act provides for final dismissal in three cases:

  1. When there are no rational indications that the act which gave rise to the case was committed.
  2. When the act does not constitute an offence: for example, a breach of contract reported as fraud.
  3. When the suspects are exempt from criminal liability, for example because of self-defence.

Once it is final, it has the effect of res judicata: the same facts cannot be investigated again against the same person.

Provisional dismissal

Article 641 provides for provisional dismissal:

  1. When the commission of the offence is not duly established.
  2. When it is clear that an offence was committed, but there are not enough grounds to charge specific persons.

This is the most common type. The case is closed, but it can be reopened if new evidence appears before the offence becomes time-barred.

Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

Differences

FinalProvisional
WhenThe act did not happen, is not an offence or the suspect is exemptThere is not enough evidence of the offence or of the offender
EffectDefinitive, like an acquittalCase closed with the possibility of reopening
ReopeningNoYes, with new evidence and while not time-barred

When it is ordered

Dismissal can be ordered at the end of the investigation in the preliminary investigation (diligencias previas), at the request of the public prosecutor or the defence or on the court's own initiative, or later, if the prosecuting parties do not file an indictment. It can also be ordered in proceedings for a minor offence, when the act is of very little seriousness and there is no public interest in prosecuting it.

Do you have a trial coming up?

We review your case without obligation and explain your real options.

Appeals

The dismissal order can be challenged by an appeal for reconsideration before the same judge and by an appeal before the Provincial Court of the Balearic Islands (Audiencia Provincial). The private prosecutor can appeal so that the investigation continues or the case goes to trial. If provisional dismissal was ordered when final dismissal was appropriate, the defence can appeal to have it declared final.

After the case is closed

Dismissal does not create a criminal record. Police records of the arrest or investigation may remain, and their deletion can be requested, as we explain in deleting police records. If the case is not dismissed, the proceedings move on to trial, where the presumption of innocence applies in full. For foreign residents, a final dismissal is also important when applying for residence permits or certificates of good conduct.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between final and provisional dismissal?

Final dismissal closes the case for good because the act did not happen, is not an offence or the suspect is exempt. Provisional dismissal closes it for lack of evidence and allows it to be reopened if new evidence appears.

Can a dismissed case be reopened?

If the dismissal is provisional, yes, with new evidence and as long as the offence is not time-barred. If it is final and no longer open to appeal, no.

Does a dismissal leave a record?

It does not leave a criminal record. There may be an entry in police files, whose deletion can be requested.

Can the victim appeal against the dismissal?

Yes, through an appeal for reconsideration and an appeal, so that further investigative steps are taken or the proceedings continue.

How long is there to appeal?

The appeal for reconsideration must be lodged within 3 days and the appeal within 5 days of notification of the order.

You may also be interested in