Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Criminal law guide

The plea agreement (conformidad) in criminal proceedings in Mallorca: what it is, when it pays and its effects

The conformidad is the agreement by which the accused accepts the facts, the legal classification and the penalty sought by the prosecution, and the trial ends without evidence being taken, with a conviction. Well negotiated, it can greatly reduce the penalty and avoid prison; badly handled, it means giving up your defence. We explain how it works and when it is advisable.

What the conformidad is

The conformidad is a way of ending criminal proceedings in which the defence and the accused accept the most serious indictment, or a new one signed jointly by all the parties. The new indictment may not refer to different facts or contain a more serious classification than the previous one. In practice, it is the result of a negotiation between the defence and the public prosecutor (and, where applicable, the private prosecutor) on the facts, the offence, mitigating circumstances and the penalty.

It is not a mere formality. The judge or court checks three things: that the classification is correct, that the penalty is legally appropriate and that the accused gives consent freely and aware of the consequences. If in doubt about the latter, the court orders the trial to continue (art. 787 ter.4).

The three routes to a conformidad in the Mallorca courts

ProcedureWhenLegal basis
Ordinary procedure (offences punishable by more than 9 years)When responding to the indictment or at the start of the trialArts. 655 and 694-697 Criminal Procedure Act
Abbreviated procedureIn the defence brief, in a joint brief or before evidence starts to be takenArts. 784.3 and 787 ter Criminal Procedure Act
Fast-track trialBefore the duty court, with a one-third reduction of the penaltyArts. 779.1.5ª and 801 Criminal Procedure Act

The "rewarded" conformidad in fast-track trials

Article 801 of the Criminal Procedure Act allows the accused to agree before the duty court with an automatic one-third reduction of the penalty sought, even below the minimum set by the Criminal Code. It requires that:

  1. No private prosecution has been brought and the public prosecutor has filed an indictment on the spot (if there is a private prosecutor, agreement can be given with the most serious indictment in the defence brief, art. 801.5).
  2. The offence is punishable by up to three years' imprisonment, a fine of any amount or another type of penalty not exceeding 10 years.
  3. In the case of imprisonment, the penalty sought, reduced by one third, does not exceed two years.

This route is also open when, in preliminary proceedings, the suspect, assisted by a lawyer, admits the facts before the judge (art. 779.1.5ª). It is common in road traffic offences, theft or minor injuries, and is handled by the duty investigating sections in Palma, Inca or Manacor. More details in our guide to the fast-track trial.

Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

What effects the conformidad has

  • Immediate judgment: it is delivered orally and, if the parties will not appeal, the judge declares it final on the spot (art. 787 ter.6).
  • Suspension of the sentence: at the same hearing the judge decides, after hearing the parties, on suspending or substituting the penalty. That is why the agreement is often negotiated so that the penalty does not exceed two years and a suspended sentence can be granted.
  • Civil liability: in the fast-track trial, a commitment to pay compensation within the period set by the court is enough to suspend the penalty (art. 801.3). If the accused only disagrees about compensation, the trial is limited to that point (arts. 655.4 and 695).
  • Criminal record: a judgment by agreement is a conviction and creates a criminal record, which can be expunged after the statutory periods.
  • Very limited appeal: only if the judgment fails to respect the requirements or terms of the agreement, never to dispute the substance of what was accepted (art. 787 ter.7).

When does a conformidad in Mallorca pay off, and when not?

A conformidad is worth considering when the prosecution evidence is strong (for example, a breath test with an approved device or clear video footage), when the reduction avoids prison or when the damage has been repaired and the mitigating circumstance of reparation can apply (art. 21.5ª of the Criminal Code). It also saves the stress and costs of a trial.

It is not advisable if the evidence is weak or was obtained in breach of rights, if there is a real chance of acquittal at the trial or if a conviction would have serious additional consequences: for a foreign national, for example, a conviction may affect residence status, and for some professionals it may lead to disqualification. The decision is always the accused's, informed by the lawyer, who must also provide written information about the agreement reached (art. 787 ter.4).

The victim's voice

Before an agreement, the prosecutor must hear the victim or injured party, even if not a party to the proceedings, where possible and necessary, and in any event if the act is especially serious or the victim is particularly vulnerable (arts. 655.2 and 787 ter.1).

If there are several defendants and not all of them agree, the trial continues (art. 655.1). Where the accused is a legal person, agreement is given by its specially designated representative with a special power of attorney and does not bind the trial of the other defendants (art. 787 ter.8). At Castell Abogados we analyse the evidence before advising on any conformidad. Call us on 684 450 450.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Is a conformidad the same as pleading guilty?

In practice, yes: the accused accepts the facts, the classification and the penalty, and a conviction is delivered without trial. That is why it should only be accepted after reviewing the evidence with your lawyer.

How much is the penalty reduced with a conformidad?

In the fast-track trial under article 801 of the Criminal Procedure Act, the penalty sought is reduced by one third. In other procedures there is no automatic reduction, only what is negotiated with the prosecution within the legal limits.

Can I appeal a judgment by agreement afterwards?

Only if the requirements or terms of the agreement were not respected. You cannot appeal to dispute the substance of what you freely accepted.

Does a conformidad keep me out of prison?

Not always, but it is often negotiated so that the penalty does not exceed two years and the judge can suspend it if the legal requirements are met.

Does it create a criminal record?

Yes. It is a final conviction and is entered in the Central Register of Convicted Persons. The record can be expunged once the statutory periods have passed without reoffending.

You may also be interested in