Law firm in Palma de Mallorca

Criminal law guide

Undue delay as a mitigating factor

When criminal proceedings drag on for an extraordinary and unjustified length of time, the defendant is entitled to have that delay compensated by a reduction in the sentence. This is the mitigating factor of undue delay (atenuante de dilaciones indebidas), one of the most frequently applied in practice by the Spanish courts.

Requirements

Article 21.6 of the Criminal Code requires:

  1. An extraordinary delay: a delay that goes far beyond the normal length of similar proceedings.
  2. That it is undue: not justified by the complexity of the case (number of suspects, expert reports, letters rogatory to other countries).
  3. That it is not attributable to the accused: delays the accused caused themselves do not count, for example because their whereabouts were unknown or because they lodged delaying appeals.

The courts assess both the total length of the proceedings and the specific periods during which the case was at a standstill with no action taken at all.

Ordinary and highly qualified mitigating factor

TypeWhenEffect
OrdinaryExtraordinary and undue delaySentence in its lower half, if no other circumstances apply
Highly qualifiedParticularly serious delay, normally several years at a standstill or a very disproportionate total lengthSentence reduced by one or two degrees

Case law has applied the highly qualified mitigating factor in proceedings that lasted more than eight or ten years without justification, or with standstills of several years, although each case depends on its complexity.

Have you been summoned or arrested?

What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.

An example calculation

Take the case of aggravated fraud, punishable by imprisonment of 1 to 6 years, in proceedings that have lasted nine years with two standstills of more than a year each without any action. With the ordinary mitigating factor, the sentence would be imposed in its lower half: between 1 year and 3 years and 6 months. If it is treated as highly qualified and the sentence is reduced by one degree, it would fall between 6 months and 1 year less one day, which would also make it possible to request the suspension of its execution.

How it is raised

The defence must invoke it in its written defence submission or in the final conclusions at the trial, setting out the key dates of the proceedings and the periods of inactivity. It is advisable to prepare a timeline of the preliminary investigation (diligencias previas) and the trial, showing the days on which the case was at a standstill. If the court does not apply it, it can be raised again on appeal.

Why it matters

A reduction can bring the sentence below two years' imprisonment and allow the suspension of its execution, avoiding prison. In complex financial crime cases, which often last many years, it is an argument that is almost always present. For foreign defendants who have left Mallorca while the case drags on, a well-documented claim of undue delay can make a decisive difference to the final outcome; we can review your file in English, German, Spanish and Mallorquin.

Has something similar happened to you?

Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.

Frequently asked questions

How long must a case last for the mitigating factor to apply?

There is no fixed period. It depends on the complexity of the case. The court assesses whether the total length or the standstills are extraordinary and unjustified.

Does it apply if the delay was my fault?

No. Delays attributable to the accused, such as their whereabouts being unknown, do not count.

How much is the sentence reduced?

As an ordinary mitigating factor, the sentence is normally imposed in its lower half. As a highly qualified one, it is reduced by one or two degrees.

Do I have to ask for it or does the court apply it of its own accord?

It is advisable to raise it expressly and document the delays. The court can apply it of its own motion, but the defence must make sure it is considered.

Can I claim compensation for the delay?

In addition to the mitigating factor, in some cases a claim can be brought against the State for the abnormal functioning of the justice system.

You may also be interested in