Which judgments can be appealed and to which Balearic court
Since Organic Law 1/2025, the former single-judge courts have been merged into Courts of First Instance (Tribunales de Instancia), organised into sections (criminal, investigating, violence against women and so on). The system of appeals follows the same logic: each judgment is reviewed by the next court up.
| Judgment appealed | Court that decides | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal section (abbreviated procedure) | Provincial Court | 10 days (art. 790) |
| Criminal section in a fast-track trial | Provincial Court | 5 days (art. 803) |
| Minor offence trial | Provincial Court, sitting with a single judge | 5 days (art. 976) |
| Provincial Court at first instance | Civil and Criminal Chamber of the High Court | 10 days (art. 846 ter) |
| Jury Court | Civil and Criminal Chamber of the High Court | 10 days (art. 846 bis b) |
In Mallorca, appeals against judgments of the criminal sections in Palma are decided by the Provincial Court of the Balearic Islands, sitting in Palma, while appeals against judgments of the Provincial Court itself or of the Jury Court go to the High Court of Justice of the Balearic Islands.
Appeal deadlines: how they are counted
Deadlines run from the day after notification of the judgment and are counted in working days: Saturdays, Sundays and public holidays do not count (art. 182 of the Judiciary Act). As a general rule, the days of August and those between 24 December and 6 January do not count either, except for steps that the law declares urgent (art. 183 of the Judiciary Act).
The abbreviated procedure has a useful rule: within three days of notification, the parties may request a copy of the recording of the trial, and the deadline for appealing is suspended until it is handed over (art. 790.1 of the Criminal Procedure Act). Reviewing the recording is essential to build a sound appeal based on an error in the assessment of the evidence.
Cross-appeals
A party that did not appeal in time may join another party's appeal at the submissions stage, but its appeal depends on the main appellant maintaining theirs (art. 790.1 of the Criminal Procedure Act).
What you do in the next few hours is decisive. Call us before making any statement.
Grounds of a criminal appeal
The notice of appeal is lodged with the court that gave the judgment and must set out the grounds in an orderly way (art. 790.2 of the Criminal Procedure Act):
- Breach of procedural rules and safeguards: for example, evidence wrongly refused or a breach of the right of defence. If the appellant seeks a declaration that the trial was null, they must cite the rules infringed, explain how they were left without a defence and show that they asked for the defect to be remedied at first instance where possible.
- Error in the assessment of the evidence: the appeal must show that the judge assessed the evidence in an illogical, arbitrary or incomplete way. This is the defence's most common ground and is usually linked to a breach of the presumption of innocence.
- Infringement of legal rules: errors in the legal classification of the offence, in applying mitigating or aggravating circumstances, in the sentence or in civil liability.
In jury judgments the grounds are more restricted (art. 846 bis c of the Criminal Procedure Act) and, for several of them, an objection must have been made at the time of the infringement.
Evidence on appeal
The only evidence that can be requested on appeal is evidence that could not be proposed at first instance, evidence wrongly refused (if an objection was lodged at the time) and evidence admitted but not taken for reasons not attributable to the party requesting it (art. 790.3 of the Criminal Procedure Act). If evidence is admitted, or the court considers it necessary, a hearing is held (art. 791).
What the appeal court in the Balearic Islands can decide
- Uphold the judgment.
- Reverse it in whole or in part: acquit the defendant, reduce the sentence or correct the civil liability.
- Set it aside and send the case back for a retrial, stating whether a different judge must hear it (art. 792.2 of the Criminal Procedure Act).
There is an important limit: where the prosecution appeals on the ground of an error in assessing the evidence, the appeal judgment cannot convict someone who was acquitted or increase the sentence; at most it can set the judgment aside, and only if its reasoning is insufficient, irrational or departs from common experience (arts. 790.2 and 792.2 of the Criminal Procedure Act).
The appeal judgment is given within five days of the hearing, or within ten days of the court receiving the case file if there is no hearing (art. 792.1), and it is also notified to the victims and injured parties even if they did not take part in the proceedings.
After the appeal: cassation
A judgment given on appeal can only be challenged by an appeal in cassation to the Supreme Court in the cases set out in article 847 of the Criminal Procedure Act. If the appeal was decided by the Provincial Court, cassation is limited to infringement of substantive law on the facts already found proven (art. 849.1). If it was decided by the High Court of Justice, cassation is broader. If no further appeal is lodged, the judgment becomes final and is enforced.
Preparing an appeal means studying the recording of the criminal trial, the judgment and the case file in a very few days. At Castell Abogados we review criminal judgments handed down in Palma, Inca, Manacor and the rest of Spain. Call us on 684 450 450 as soon as you receive notification.
Tell us about your case: the first consultation is free and without obligation.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to appeal a criminal judgment?
Ten working days in the abbreviated procedure and against judgments of the Provincial Court or the Jury Court; five days in fast-track trials and minor offence trials.
Can my position get worse if I appeal?
If only you appeal, the court cannot increase your sentence. If the prosecution also appeals, the court cannot convict you or increase the sentence because of an error in assessing the evidence, although it could set the judgment aside.
Can I submit new evidence on appeal?
Only evidence you could not propose at first instance, evidence wrongly refused after you objected, and evidence admitted but not taken for reasons beyond your control.
Is there a hearing on appeal?
Not always. A hearing is held if evidence is admitted or if the court considers it necessary. Otherwise, the appeal is decided on the written submissions and the trial recording.
Can the appeal judgment be challenged?
In some cases an appeal in cassation to the Supreme Court is possible, with very limited grounds where the appeal was decided by the Provincial Court.